Reflections of a Drowning Tree

Please give me some feedback on this image. Thanks for any

comments/ratings!

 

Shane Moore

Beautiful grayscale. Nice reflection. Good job! :)

i like it but ... i would have liked to see all of the circle at the bottom ...

:)

vonsh

That's what I call good B/W photography ! I'm not sure, if this picture would be better with the full circle...

Nice shot. I agree with the others regarding the ripples. Full circle closer to the tree, maybe getting into the reflection.

This is an excellent black and white. I would like to not see the ripple in the foreground because I think it detracts from the subject. I love it!

Wonderful Idea and fantastic BW. Good framing and cnocept. Thanxs for sharing photos like this. T H I S I S A R T !|

So peaceful!

very good picture. the title is over the top, though.

I would say I know that tree -- except the one I know is too far away for this perspective-- part of the soothing universality here. The broken circle adds the connection to the rest of the universe, perhaps, though suggests serenity about to be rocked (slightly). Good.

Excellent B&W-photo, congratulations!

 

Very nice. I'm torn about the ripple, though. It should be neater given how clean the rest of the composition is, I think.

Outstandingly executed. I think I'd like it better with the ripple cropped out of the bottom. I think the proportions would be better too.