single photos Tower B/W

Need opinion is this better in black and white, or in color. Color

photo is also in portfolio. Comments, suggestions, critiques and

ratings welcomed. Thanks.

I like them both. I prefer the B&W over the color. There is only one thing that I see. The tree on the left is a good organic contrast, but we lose the tree that directly in front of the tower. Those three trees and the branches on the right frame the tower beautifully, but we lose that frame without the tree. Ironically, we gain that frame from the defused shadow at the base of the tower, but I would like to see it framed by the tree itself.

 

I still think it's a beautiful peice, thanks for sharing it.

Thank you for your comment, I really appreciate it. I hope I'll get more constructive comments from you in the future. Thanks!