Robert showing off on 'The Warmup Problem'

This could be good except for it being too dark overall and having no detail in shadow areas. Sometimes a silhouette can be dramatic, but in this case it just looks like underexposure.

Even thought this picture is very dark, I would say it's neither salvagable nor a total loss. Given enough time and patience in Photoshop you can bring out the elements so that you have something that's impressionistic at best, but it won't be sold to any magazines.

I think it might look better if the bottom was cropped off so only the siloete and sky are visible.

Along the lines of this? (Still haven't gotten down how to un-darken the sky, but I'm not a big photoshopper)