Wisner or Deardorf

[tim_kimbler]

I'm trying to make a decision as to what camera to purchase. My reading has lead me to believe that a used Wisner Technical or Deardorf would be the best camera in my price range, around 1500.00 dollars. I have a 210mm and 90mm lens, and plan on purchasing a 360mm. I spend most of my time out doors shooting landscapes, but want to be able to do some still life and portriates. My first camera was a Tachihara and I now want something built better with in my price range. Any thoughts on which camera will be best for me, and will last many years?

[sean_yates]

FWIW, $.02, IMHO.....gallopping caveats

 

<p>

 

Check out the various threads on this page and see Wisner's home page.

 

<p>

 

Kind of subjective. The stainless steel and nickle of the 'dorff is

nice and the sturdiness & longevity of workmanship & design have been

proven since 1923. Some folks will use nothing else.

 

<p>

 

Wisner has front shift, front forward base tilt & interchangeable

bellows, plus rear axis tilt which is nice to have, but you can get

by without. Rear rise is dicussed in another thread. Folks have

complained about the difficulty of using wide lenses with the

Wisner. The 'dorff rear focuses all the way forward. The new Pocket

Expedition addresses this issue by adapting the 'dorff approach,

although the execution is different. Also, with the 'dorff sliding

lens panel you can still use a little r&f with the bellows squashed

flat.

 

<p>

 

Both have good resale potential. 'dorff is kinda like a Ford as far

as getting parts & getting it worked on, even though they went outta

bidness in '88. For the Wisner, if you go used you can save a

little, if you bang around you may find a 2nd hand bag belllows &

lens boards, but you may as well go new unless the budget is real

tight. I haven't used a 4X5/5X7 'dorff, but the 8X10 is

easier/faster to open and set up than my 4X5 & 5X7 Wisners were.

 

<p>

 

When all is said and done, try to get your hands on both, maybe rent

one of each and see how YOU relate to it. That's really going to be

the telling factor, your personal response to either. I was amazed

at the ease and speed with which I can use my most recent

acquisition, a Kodak Master View. It's almost as if I think the same

way as the designers did. Although some may be surprised I think at

all.

[tim_kimbler]

Thanks, I don't think I can get the newer camera, Special, in my price

range. Do the older models have the movements needed for what I want

to do? Most likely I will buy a camera from Shutterbug and won't be

able to see it in advance.

[gary_frost3]

With your experience on the Tachihara, you should have a good idea

what and how much movements you need. Also what you do and do not like

about the Tachihara will influence your choice on a second/new 4X5.

I would suggest that you cannot make a good choice without trying the

various models first. See if you can get to a camera show to try them.

 

<p>

 

P.S. Do you have the newer or older Tachihara? I bought the new one in

August this year and find it simply wonderful to work with. I have no

need for a 360mm lens though....

 

<p>

 

Happy hunting.