elinchrom El Octa 74" Profoto Giant Umbrella Reflectors w/ optional diffuser

[seanduckett]

I'm looking into pick up up some thing like this. i plan to rent both side by

side and do some comparisons. however i was wonder in anybody out there have any

opinions on these units, difference, quality, ETC. they seem very similar (if

you use one of the optional diffusers with the Profoto). any input is appreciated.

 

thanks.

[borispale]

Actually the light is not as close as you may think when the 7foot profoto reflector is compared to the 190cm elinchrom okta. The elinchrom okta is a tad softer and very even. The profoto is a bit more sparkling.

Personally I prefer the elinchrom look and the engineering idea/build/quality is just incredible. You can set the Elinchrom Okta up in less than a minute yourself. It basicly opens just like an umbrella.

 

The profoto is more work, needs more time and a whole lot more studio space.

 

Best thing in fact is that you rent and see for yourself what fits your needs/taste.

 

best

 

boris

[seanduckett]

thanks boris. this is the kind of info that i was looking for. i was considering picking up a 5x7 larson soff box for it's soft even light from center to edge but then again i'm one of those who prefer the circular type catch light and notice that there wasn't much difference in price.

 

 

anymore opinion would be appreciated.

 

thanks.