WTB: Nikon 24mm or 35mm lens

The vignetting on my 28mm f3.5 drives me a little crazy, so I'd like to pick up either a Nikkor-N 24mm f2.8 or Nikkor-S 35mm f2.8 lens. Ai'd or Non-Ai is fine. Single-coated, please. Thanks!

Vignetting is fairly easily corrected for in a large number of photo editors (e.g., Adobe Camera Raw).

 

Wide angles on "full frame" will have some vignetting as an inevitable consequence of how the light at the edges of the lens is 'funneled" into the lens in relation to the image plane.

Thanks JDM - the Nikon 28mm tends toward hard vignetting (completely black corners) with a polarizer and/or its dedicated hood. I can get around it with a 52-77 step up ring and a big polarizer, but it makes the lens much less compact. I'm hoping to try one of the other two see if they are better. I like Nikon's early F designs and would like to stick to lenses introduced in the first couple of generations.

I have a good Nikkor 24mm f/2.8 which sees little use. I cannot now figure out how to send e-mail.

I'm not sure how to send emails either - mine is funkag at yahoo dot com

Have sent e-mail.

addendum:

 

one explanation of vignetting on wide angle and large aperture lenses at

• https://photographylife.com/w