Jump to content

Red filter for portraits?


Recommended Posts

I heard you can get the cool gothic look with it. Once i'll try it out. In the same time, i'd also like to see some examples.

 

Btw, i guess you mean shoot in black and white with the red filter. I wonder if you can simulate red filter in photoshop, and to what extent, when converting a colour portrait to black and white, after pumping up the red channel.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Basically, a red filter used with panchromatic film will render subjects with red in them lighter, and subjects with blue in them darker, or just the opposite of Orthochromatic films. Technical Pan is very red sensitive, and works well for some portraits, but it can be overdone, leading to very harsh skin tone rendition, especially with high contrast. Here's an image from TP, which will approximate the use of a light red filter with more normal pan films.<div>008zNA-18957184.thumb.jpg.93072eacfa1af23897c2158146de79f8.jpg</div>
Link to comment
Share on other sites

First of all, the best way to deal with this is in the digital domain rather than a filter on the lens. It gives a choice on usage and allows fine tuning the filter.<p>

 

Second, although Tom has produced a beautiful example of conversion with a red filter effect, he doesn't give a comparison without the filter. The images below were created with a black and white conversion tool that also gives a choice of filter during conversion. Even if you are going to use a filter on the camera, the effect is similar.<p>

 

<center><img src="http://www.spirer.com/images/filtercompare.jpg">

<br>Filter Comparison, Copyright 2004 Jeff Spirer</i></center>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi people. I've got another newbie question regarding filters for B&W portrait.

<p>

What's the effect of light green filter on skin tones? With red filter, the lips look too light and less appealing. Green filter should makes the lips darker, right? But does green filter cause skin blemishes such as freckles to be more visible?

<p>

Thanks in advance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you plan on using a red filter for a portrait, you make-up has to done with that in mind. Best was to see more or less what you will get is too look at the model through a piece of red gel, you will notice how some colours blend together, but others increase in contrast.

 

If you shoot digital, then just use PS or similar, if you shoot B+W film, then use the filter. I think you just can't get the same effect in PS as you can on B+W film, nothing you can see on a computer screen, but the prints show the difference, even the C41 B+W prints look better.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

<i>If you shoot digital, then just use PS or similar, if you shoot B+W film, then use the filter. I think you just can't get the same effect in PS as you can on B+W film, nothing you can see on a computer screen, but the prints show the difference, even the C41 B+W prints look better.

 

</i><p>

 

This depends on your skill as a printer, or the quality of the Fronteir lab used. Well-done digital prints will be fine, especially since most people do their c41 black and white at a minilab.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So many red filter questions?Generally the only color contrast filters commonly used in B&W portrait work are the light and medium geen.These are used with pale skin to prevent it from looking "chalky",and sometimes to bring out texture in men's portraits.Red or orange will indeed suppress/remove blemishes,but its effect on lips,skin,red or blonde hair is to render them too light.Blue eyes will go too dark.IMHO,red filters cause more troubles than they are worth (even for landscapes),due to the printing problems all that contrast creates.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...