Jump to content

How close did the Ukrainians come to cloning the Minox?


daniel_iggers

Recommended Posts

Is the Kiev 35A a Poor Man's Minox, or a poor copy with a completely different lens?

 

<p>

 

I bought a wounded Minox EL at a garage sale last year. In spite of the wobbly support for the cover, I found it exquisite. I've always liked fine compact 35mm cameras; I'd owned a Rollei 35 as a teenager.

 

<p>

 

The $30 garage sale Minox turned out to have a broken circuit board, and the $200-plus estimate was too much for me.

 

<p>

 

More recently, I've "won" an auction on Ebay for a Kiev 35A, which is supposedly a close copy of a Minox 35EL, made in the Ukraine. It cost me USD$40 plus $5 shipping, but has not arrived yet.

 

<p>

 

I understand that Kiev and other cameras from the former Soviet Union can be unreliable and can vary greatly in fit and finish. What I'm wondering is whether any readers of Martin Tai's Minox Forum have had any experience with the Kiev 35A, and in particular what people who have examined and use the camera think of the quality of the lens and the photos it produces.

 

<p>

 

(Yes, I intend to buy another used Minox, once I come up with a working model at the right price.)

 

<p>

 

Dan Iggers

Toronto

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Daniel, I have always interested in Kiev 35A, but never own one. AFAIK, Kiev 35A is a copy of Minox EL, with a Kiev designed lens.

<p>The most frequent complain about Kiev 35A is light leak, you have to buy some black tap to tap around the light leak spot.

The body is just plastic, not like Minox EL made of glass fibre re-enfourced Macrolon.

<p> However, the Kiev 35A lens is a good performer. Kiev Ukraine does make good optics.

<p> We all know that former Zeiss factory in former W. Germany ended up in Ukraine at end of WWII.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

I too have been interested in the Kiev clone of the Minox 35, so

recently, like you, I bought one through eBay ($39 plus shipping).

 

<p>

 

The camera is an obvious knock-off of the Minox 35. It looks like

they just made an exact copy of everything. It has a rather ugly

green finish and is not nearly as smooth as a Minox, but nevertheless

is an interesting conversation piece.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My Kiev 35A did arrive, and I have been using it. After some fiddling

to arrive at the right battery (four 44's stacked did not do the

trick; a 5.6 v something or other 27 did), I've been using it. I have

not had my first roll developed yet.

 

<p>

 

I did show the camera to someone who works at Alt Cameras, one of our

"pro" camera shops in Toronto. That person, who owned Minox 35s for

many years, was impressed. He said the Russian glass is superb, and

he said either that optically there should be no difference or that

the Russian glass might be better than the German.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

I had a discussion with a shop assistant in a used gear shop two

days ago. He had a Minox-like camera on display there. The camera

bore the "Minox" sign on its front panel. There was no "Minoxar" or

"Minotar" inscription on the lens, however. Also the price was

unbelievable low. The shop assistant did not know the origin of the

camera but his colleague admitted that it could be a Russian or

Ukrainian copy of Minox.

 

<p>

 

I know that the former Soviet Union made copies of cameras or

electric razors (as Braun or Philips) and sold them in the Soviet

block but the brand name of the copies differed from the originals.

I have never met such a fake.

 

<p>

 

Jan Chleboun

Prague, Czech Republic

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...

Last week my new Kiev 35 arrived, and after I ran a test film through

it I was surprised at how good the results were. Obviously I've been

lucky and received one that doesn't leak light, but after I had

worked out the idiosyncrasies of the metering parameters, learnt not

to leave my thumb on the back of the camera while winding on (it jams

the film, which may break), and realised that the winding lever needs

two throws to wind on, I was quite happy with it.

 

<p>

 

In case you wonder why I didn't obtain that information by reading

the user's manual, it was in Russian or Ukrainian only, and although

I can read the alphabet I can't understand the words...

 

<p>

 

I can definitely say now that the lens is considerably sharper than

the lens on the Minox. I was using ISO 800 colour print film, and

overexposed by two stops at that, but the clarity of the fine detail

is astonishing.

 

<p>

 

Has the Kiev got the same build quality of the Minox? Of course not,

but if you get one that works properly, it is a very suitable camera

for keeping with you all the time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

I also am on the path of discovery of the 35A - just sourced new off

ebay. Not having the lingo (instr bk Russian) I am puzzled by the

battery - the 6 volt one from my Minox (yup, the real thing) just

does not quite fit the comparment - unable to screw the lid on.

 

<p>

 

Anyone been along this way ?

cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

hey, well I've owned about 4 kiev 35a camera's and I had troubles

with all of them. whit the first one I had great troubles with the

lightmeter, because when the meter didn't reach above the 1/30 it

just felt out, so everytime when that happend i lose a picture, the

second one didn,t worked at all, the third one had a bad connection

between the shutter and the light meter and the fourth one only

worked for about 15 pictures, so now I bought a minox

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 4 months later...

I bought one of the teeny kiev from that guy from san fran on ebay.

At first I thought it was a hunk of crap, but the lens looked good,

glass wise.. The lack of any kind of light seal foam and loose fit

of the back/bottom can be scary- I gotta refoam all my old

rangefinders so maybe I can invent a way to foam the kiev.

 

<p>

 

When I first opened the box and tried to fold the lens out, it was

so stiff i had to be careful not to break it. It freed up and opens

out smoothly (relatively) after about two rolls of film and playing

with it for a while. For batteries I was stumped, and that's why

I'm poking around here now- seeing what the battery deal is-

 

<p>

 

My sister-in-law is ukrainian and I got her to look through the

manual and manual supplements for information about the battery.

To my chagrin (and her amusement) one of the supplements to the

manual said that the batteries for the camera will no longer be

produced. But the factory still makes the camera... She was amused

as that was how things worked in the bad ol' days.. Big ol'

factories turning out products that can't be used.

 

<p>

 

Anyway, I went to my local drug store that I hate, and opened every

battery that looked like it had a remote chance of fitting.

I found that two DL 1/3 N cells fit perfectly and total six volts.

 

<p>

 

I have read that for light meters the mercury types are best with

mecury oxide being the second choice. So knowing that I tried four

357 cells and it works perfect. The 357 cells cost about 1/3 what

the 44 whatever cells cost, but they are silver oxide and have the

same specifications. So my guess is four 357 cells are what you

need.

 

<p>

 

Oh- I really like the camera cause it looks like such a hunk of crap

that you don't need to lock your car doors and you don't sweat it

when you leave it in a cheap hotel room in scary foreign lands..

 

<p>

 

It's kinda like a kodak disposeable with a killer glass european

lens on it..

awesome!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was just tinkering around with my 35a kiev and trying to 'cipher a

way to make the back feel more secure and not leak light when it

dawned on me.. Bolt it on!

 

<p>

 

Get a good-looking pan head or socket head (these even come in black

) 1/4 inch by 20 thread bolt (tripod mount bolt sized).

Select or cut it to be about the same length as the tripod mounting

bolt and screw it into the tripod mounting threads, securing the

removeable bottom/back to the body..

 

<p>

 

This will hold the bottom on better than ever!

 

<p>

 

Joy!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Regarding the Kiev 35A, I have a gray/green one and it leaked

light along the top edge of the removable back. I understand that

this is due to light passing through the thin area of the back and

that the black model does not have this problem. I have painted this

area black on mine with black acrylic fabric paint, but have not had

a chance to test it yet. I agree that the lens is great. Also BE

SURE to use the plastic tube if you use four bare batteries (such as

type 76 or LR44, the battery chamber tube is made of metal and the

batteries will short out rendering the camera inoperable and can ruin

the camera.

Charles

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

I've really want to like this camera. I've got a small electric flash

that goes great with it, flash in one pocket, kiev in the other. The

problem is that the cameras don't seem to work for me. I don't know

if I'm much harder on them, or if I've just got bad luck, but I've

had three of them now, and they all seem broken.<br>

I actually ordered two from over in Ukraine, knowing that Russians

often aren't the best with QC. One arrived about a week later, and

the shutter didn't seem to be working. So I sent it back, and

reminded the guy that I had ordered and paid for two. A couple weeks

later, they arrived. I remember checking the shutters on both right

away, and they seemed to be in working order. But after running a

couple rolls of film through one of them, the shutter seems to have

quit working. I was going to just switch to the other one, but that

one seems to be dead two.<br>

I'm tempted to run another roll through in case the camera actually

is working.... it makes a click noise, but when I have the back off,

and am looking through it, I can only see light coming through when

it's set to higher apertures. I looked through the back of my cannon,

and I can see light coming through even at higher speeds.<br>

Has anyone had problems like this? The only thing I can think of that

would have killed my backup is that I left it in my car overnight

when it was really cold out. I can't imagine why that would damage it

though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 months later...

Here's an answer to those light leaks. I've had problems off and on with my

Kiev 35A (I love the little beast). I've tried black tape along the top edge of the

back casing but nothing seemed to work 100%. It turns out entire plastic body

leaks light to some degree, especially the back/bottom casing. This individual

painted his entire case and it seems to have fixed it. I'm going to try it myself.

 

<p>

 

http://www.geocities.com/markhahn2000/fixing_light_leaks_in_a_kiev_35a.ht

ml

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...
I have had two of the little beasts - nice lenses, but the finish as another story - the first one, the shutter stopped working very soon after I had it, and never came back from the dead, so I bought another, same cost, just as new, but on this one, there was a very bad light leak, so I taped it up with gaffer tape, but was not able to see if it worked, as the shutter on this one also went and stopped on me; I now stay with the real thing - I have just bought another EL on ebay for $43. Peter Booker
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...