Jump to content

FL and coverage for 11x14 Series V Protar?


clyde_rogers

Recommended Posts

There are many different coverage figures one sees for the Protar V designs - between B&L and Zeiss catalouges, you typically see a full plate size difference. The typical coverage angle quoted is 11 degrees but this is for small stops (i.e., f/45) and at wider stops I think a figure of 95-100 degrees is more realistic.

 

As far as I know, the Protar Vs were available in 141mm, 183mm and about 210mm. The 141 is really meant for a 5x7 but will cover 8x10 quite nicely at small stops (i.e., f/45). The 183 is suggested for 8x10 but again is supposed to cover 11x14 at small stops. You need about 450mm minimum to cover an 11x14 frame. The 210mm will manage that very nicely even at wider stops and with a bit of stopping down will even give you reasonably modest movements. The 183mm is going to find it difficult to reach the corners even stoped down and I suspect even if it makes it, the corners will not look particularly good.

 

You can find the true focal length by autocollimating but the quickest way to do it might be to focus on a scale or coin till you get a 1:1 magnification on the ground glass i.e., same size image on the ground glass. Measure the bellows extension and divide by 2 and that should give you a pretty close approximation to the tru focal length.

 

Cheers, DJ

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Clyde,

 

I've used the 183mm Protar V. The one I had did not cover 11x14, it's image

circle fell short at small stops. OTOH, Kerik also has the same lens and says

his covers 7x17 no problem so there must be some variable samples out

there. If this is the fl you're looking for 'try before you buy' would be good

advice.

 

The 210 Protar V seems to be the magic focal length that does cover 11x14

(or more) sufficiently. It's also the one you'll least likely see on the used

market.

 

Happy hunting!

 

Cheers,

Roger...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I tried the close focus test, and it gives the same 10.5" (267mm)

the catalog does. I set the lens to f64 (there's no mark for f45) at

infinity, and although I can't check it accurately on my tiny little

5x7, it is clear that the image circle easily exceeds 20 inches

before mechanical vignetting.

 

Thanks much for the useful information and advice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As far as I know there are five brands for the Protar V lenses:

-Carl Zeiss

-B&L

-Ross

-E.Krauss

-An Italy company (and I forgot the name).

 

I have this brands in different focus length. I have tested them and results that E. Krauss has the largest coverage, then Ross..Zeiss and last B&L.

If you are interest please vist my homepage at:

http://www.greenviewclub.com/Chat/CameraManual/Protar/Protar.htm

 

Edward Chung

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...