Jump to content

Do any of You LF landscape use just two lenses?


hugh_sakols

Recommended Posts

I'm still contemplating the idea of LF photography. I know with my

Mamiya TLR I avoid changing lenses. Thus, I find myself mostly using

my 180mm and 55mm. I'm wondering if I should plan on just a two lens

set up for LF to make things simpler. Landscape photographers what

two lenses would you choose? If I go into LF should I at least have

a 150mm to take advantage of its incredible sharpness and of course

reasonable price?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

>If I go into LF should I at least have a 150mm to take advantage of its incredible sharpness and of course reasonable price?

<p>

WHICH 150mm lens are you talking about? If you are talking about the 150mm Super Symmar XL, then yes it is incredibly sharp... but it isn't cheap at all...

<p>

My set:

<p>

58mm Super Angulon XL<br>

110mm Super Symmar XL<br>

180mm Apo Symmar<br>

<p>

Although, I don't use the 58mm as much as I thought I would. I would be happy with the other two.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you're going with a 4x5 and only picking two lenses, I would recommend a 75mm and a 150mm. I think you'll be very disappointed if you go with the 90mm for a wide angle for landscapes as you will need the extra coverage for more shots than you might think. You can always crop after you get the shot with the 75mm. If you go with the 90mm, you will not be able to get a lot of shots you may desire.

 

http://www.naturesfinestimages.com

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I started with a 90/8 and then added a 150/5.6. I then found my decision on which lens to used was being influenced by the ease at which I could see the image on the GG. So I traded in the dark 90 for a 80/4.5 Super-Symmar XL. But I also felt a short tele would add a valuable option. I frequently use a 35-105 on my Nikon. So the lens set that I finally settled with and don't have any yearning to add to right now (my bank manager wouldn't allow it anyway) is;

80, 150, 270. (or 23, 46, 83 in 35mm equivalents)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For my 4X5 rig, I have these lenses to choose from: 90mm, 127mm, 135mm, 163mm, 215mm, and 254mm. Which lenses I take with me when working out of the studio depends to a large degree on where I'm going and what I'm shooting. I would say that my 2 most used lenses for landscape are the 90 and 215, followed by the 163 and 127.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In school (Art Center) we were commanded to purchase a 90 and 210 for 4x5. I did everything with those two lenses, table-tops, landscapes, architecture, fashion, portraiture, for many years.

 

Lately, I have gotten clever and purchased a Nikon 150, 200, 300, all using the same 52mm filters. The back of a Schneider 110 also seems to accept this size filter. Neat.

 

With loose manufacturing tolerances, it isn't necessary to purchase every LF lens made. I have heard of 120mm lenses which were actually slightly longer than 135mm.

 

For some reason, unlike 35mm shooters, LF people don't seem to carry around a trunk full of lenses. One or two seem to do all that's necessary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hugh,

 

IMHO, start with one lens and don't be afraid to move closer or back up. You'll soon know if you need a second lens, and if it should be longer or wider. I shot landscapes for a couple of years with a 14" on an 8x10--I've never heard of anyone calling a 14" a landscape lens on an 8x10 but it worked just fine (and still does)for me.-------------Cheers!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For my first 18 months or so of 4x5 photography, I used just two lenses. A 110mm SS-XL, and a 240mm Fujinon-A. Both are sharp as can be - better lenses than I am a photograper. I used the 110mm about 60% and the 240 the other 40%.

 

Eventually it became apparent that I was missing some things that fell between those two lenses, so I picked up a 150mm Apo-Sironar-S. Now I use each lens about 33% of the time.

 

When you look at it, what I have is a set of "view angles" of 60, 45, and 30 degrees (more or less), which is why this set works for me so well.

 

You could easily start out with just a 150mm lens and do all your work with it. A 150 is a good general purpose lens. While in 20 years with 35mm, I never owned or had a need for a 50mm lens, I find the 150mm lens for 4x5 very useful indeed. Of course, YMMV.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

<p>I think it really depends on how you "see" things, Hugh. More specifically, how you'll see things in 4x5 (assuming that's the format you're thinking of). Although "equivalence" tables comparing LF to 35mm and MF are around, they don't always work out to be true. </p>

<p>You may find it helpful to walk around with a <a href="http://www.rbarkerphoto.com/misc/Photo-gear/FramingAid1-500.jpg">4x5 framing aid</a> for a few days to see which focal lengths seem more natural for your vision. (The hole is 4x5, and the knots are tied at common LF lens focal lengths. Close one eye, hold the knot to your cheek, and look through the opening to frame the "shot".)</p>

<p>Personally, I find about 80% of my 4x5 landscapes are done with either a 110mm SS XL, or a 210mm APO Symmar. On 8x10, I'm currently enthralled with the 150mm SS XL. Your vision might be completely different, however.</p>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I shoot landscape with just one lens: a Rodenstock 210mm Apo Sironar....

 

I find "limiting" myself to one lens allows me to better intuit my compositions before

setting up....and it gives a consistency to my portfolio of images that helps to unify

the disparate imagery into more of a cohesive family, all with a similar "look"....

 

a note: the 210 is used on a 5x7 Deardorff, so as far as focal legnth goes, that's a bit

north of "normal" focal legnth....I'd love to get something a bit shorter, say a 180, but

over the last ten years of shooting with it, I've grown accustomed to the 210's way of

seeing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...