What are you expect from critique?

FWIW :)

FWIW, all I've been saying is that, at any level, a photographer might well benefit from both expert and non-expert critiques and opinions, which could offer an array of perspectives. This does not seem controversial to me, especially if we add, as you suggest, that those critiquing a beginner consider explaining their degree of experience as well.

It seems like you want to maneuver me into some position.

No. I felt you misinterpreted me and was clarifying my position. If you felt maneuvered, that's on you.

FWIW, all I've been saying is that, at any level, a photographer might well benefit from both expert and non-expert critiques and opinions, which could offer an array of perspectives. This does not seem controversial to me, especially if we add, as you suggest, that those critiquing a beginner consider explaining their degree of experience as well.

Wow. It is quite a discussion here. Thank you very much, folks, for an expression of your opinions and for your honest feedback. It sounds like this is a vital topic for many people.

I agree with Sam, that any critique, both from professional and non-professional has to be taken into consideration. First, very often I rely on my wife's opinion who can tell me what she feels when looking at my picture. Yes, I agree this is "like - don't like" opinion mostly, but we can talk about details. On the other hand, professionalism and expertise are more important for your growth as a photographer, and at this degree the more you progress in your development the more you can benefit from the advice and more attention of professional photographers you can get when you asking for a review. If you are a beginner and do not understand the main principles of photography there is very little chance that real photographers from Magnum or 1x will even bother to stop by. IMO, critique is very important in all stages of your learning process.