scotttyrrell

Lovely rich, creamy tones. Superbly lighted. Very captivating and sensual. Great shot!

Very strange, disconcerting yet pleasing image. I love the play of tones, three dimensionality and texture. They all seem to interact in such a way that the viewer is not quite sure as to the verisimilitude of the image. Great shot.

Very engaging, I love the soft tones, the muted colour palette as well as the colour toning - your post is on point as always. Very nice

I commented on another shot up here of a kid, it worked because of the mood, the expression, not because of any technical excellence (although it was not lacking). This shot is technically superb. The lighting, framing and especially the processing - love the colours, the colour toning. What doesn't work is the positioning and the expression. The little girls head looks awkwardly placed and the older girl has an awkward expression as well as posture. I bet you have another photos from this shoot that although perhaps not quite so technically perfect, depict a more natural interaction and have a little more magic, as that is the only thing that this shot lacks, and perhaps the only thing out of your control!

I commented on your other image up for critique, which I prefer to this one. What I find interesting is that here your tones are much starker in comparison, the contrast is not nearly so soft - and it works here, it would not have done in the other. And although I prefer the other shot, I think the differences in processing show a great sensitivity to your subjects. Well done.

Super framing. Lovely contrast on the subject which helps separate from the background and to draw attention. I understand why you've used softer tones and raised the blacks here, it has certainly added a bunch of atmosphere. A harsher contrast would have been unflattering. Great shot!

With shots like these it is so much less about the technical elements, and almost completely about the emotion, the life. This photo has loads of both, great shot.

I like this shot, it has great mood and bags of atmosphere. Shooting mist is always a pleasure, but when, as here, there is also haze/light cloud in the sky, the temptation is always to try and drag any amount of detail out of what would otherwise be a featureless expanse of white. You have detail here, but I feel that in the quest for interest, you have burnt the sky in a tad to heavily. A lighter touch may wirk better.Totally only my opinion though! And again, a really nice shot that caught and held my eye. Thanks.

There are two interiors here; that of the truck and that of the Gleaner. And although the photo shows the truck's interior, it is the Gleaners interior that this picture truly depicts. The Gleaner seems completely lost in thought, the thought is the story. As to what that thought is, we can only guess (aided perhaps by the objects we can see), and therein lies the magic in this photo. What's your story?

I like this image, but it is too "crunchy", too noisy, too sharp for my tastes. Has a great mood though which offsets the technicalities.

Great natural portrait Siamak, very well done. 

Hey Dipankar. I think you've captured both the porters and their environment well, the hard nature of the porter's work is well depicted in your image with the two figures rising laden out of the misty valley. I think the photo is just a touch overexposed, but I know why you have done this - so as to have the two figures, the focus of this image, not lost in shadow. For me, a partial silhouette could have worked here without loosing the documentary element. Alternatively, a little work in photoshop could have helped darken the mountains and sky, as well as adding a touch more contrast. Great shot Dipankar, thanks. 

A striking high contrast image, full of emotion. Very powerful. Deep, pitch blacks and very bright whites, but almost no mid-tones, yet the tones work well here. I like that you can see just a little of the horse's flanks, and that one of the largest areas of mid-tones is that of the lady's face. Would loose the grass(?) bottom right, distracting. Great shot.

Strange conditions indeed. It is almost as though, what with the blue and yellow light, that dawn and dusk have finally met, without the day as a go-between. I love the way the "dawn" seems to wedge itself into the dusk. This image has a surreal, dreamlike quality, whilst also being quite graphic, in the design sense. The dark tree dead center work really well and seem also to be heading another wedge, this one of trees. The central horizon compliments the aforementioned qualities. This image would actually work well rotated 90 degrees or, even better, flipped upside-down with the ripples in the "sky". Maybe! Great shot.