I hope this posts at the right place as first time posting on this site. Thanks for all your help! In trying the above things, I found that the diaphragm was not working. In trying the series of exposures that William Michael recommended, as well as per Matthew Curie. They didn' t have the same exposure at all. Also, when I put it on "A" mode, I noticed regardless of what f stop I chose, the shutter speed didn't change. I did remember to try the recommendation of using a different body and tried it on my d5000. Yep, same thing happened. Tamron said it was under warranty of course, and "replaced the aperture apparatus" and it should be in my hands today. Those were all great tests I now know to use in the future....I couldn't figure out what to turn off or leave automatic to isolate the problem. (And, I did actually have a firmware update for Nikon I had no idea about. So I appreciate that info even though it didn't fix this issue.)