Digital Photography Workflow: Fine Art Photography
by Michael Ezra
Digital photography requires a solid workflow, allowing for
professional preparing of digital photo files for the web and
print. For the Digital Photography Workflow series, we consulted with
a number of experienced professional photographers who are also
stellar photo.net members and frequent contributors to the Photo.net Digital Darkroom
forum, to walk us through their specific digital photography
workflow.
In this article, Michael Ezra discusses his unique digital
workflow process tailored to meet the needs of his professional fine
art photography career, the set of software and tools he prefers to
use, and goals he accomplishes with his digital workflow. The article
is enhanced with illustrative figures and screen shots, and includes
examples of fine art photography from Michael Ezra's
portfolio. Whether you are just entering the world of digital
photography and needs some tips and advice on how best to post-process
your images, or are a seasoned pro, the insights shared here should be
helpful with your own digital photography workflow and fine art
photography post-processing.
Introduction: Challenges in Digital Photography Workflow
Michael Ezra
Effectiveness and efficiency are often hailed as the defining corner
stones and driving forces behind the progress of the modern age. This
holds especially true for the world of photography, particularly for
its execution and processing aspects—an invisible mechanism behind the
final works of art. Introduction of digital technology into
photography had a double-faced effect on the field. On one hand, it
undoubtedly brought some groundbreaking changes to the effectiveness
of the photography as a complete art medium. On the other hand, its
contribution to efficiency may be considered less certain given that
by introducing better tools digital technology unlocked a flood of new
possibilities—a flood that often threatens to overwhelm even a more
experienced photographer.
This article comes as a result of years invested in researching and
analyzing the ways to do photography better; not the artistic
fine-tuning, but the actual tools of the trade -technologies
underlying digital cameras and backs, powers of RAW processing,
pitfalls of post-processing, preparation of output for printing,
etc. My motto is simple: efficient process allows concentrating on art
while proper processing allows bringing that art to life; and I offer
this article to those readers who are looking to explore the
possibilities offered by digital technology in the studio workflow and
to master the aspects important for achieving a greater efficiency in
this field to propel their progress.
Solving the puzzle of establishing an efficient photographic studio
workflow is similar to solving any other problem for process flow: it
is possible to arrive to a solution efficiently only when requirements
for the end result are well defined. Envisioning and understanding the
end results—in our case, it can be fine art prints in a particular
size, images for the web galleries, etc.—drives the selection of
proper tools while the sequence and efficiency of their usage comes
with experience. Bottom line: a good workflow should allow achieving
desired results repeatedly, reliably, and with consistent quality.
In this article I would like to overview and share my studio workflow
specific to producing fine art photographic prints of studio
nudes. From the technical point of view, the utmost important aspect
of the end result in production of fine art prints is their
quality. Fine art prints should truly be very fine; therefore
attention to detail in every step of the process is critical. My
workflow is tuned specifically for this aspect as the highest
priority.
Figure 1: Photography Workflow
From A to Z, the workflow is defined by the following key elements:
- Where you shoot: Studio space
- How the image is formed: Lighting setup
- How the image is captured: Photographic cameras
- How the image is stored and retreived: Computer system
- How the image is prepared: Various software packages
- How the image is outputted: Photographic printer
As we go down the list, I will describe each key element individually
and also in relationship with the other elements. But before we begin,
here is a very concise look at the entire workflow (Figure 1: Photography
Workflow). This diagram lists all steps highlighting when and what
kind of results are produced, along with recommendations for storage
and back-up, and it can be used as a quick reference as you move
through the article.
I. Pre-capture
The preparatory steps described in this section do not necessarily
take place during every single photoshoot. As a matter of fact, a lot
of the decisions here are made once, and then they become just another
integral part of your routine.
Studio space
Studio space is customized based on individual project
requirements. This includes selection of specific backgrounds,
lighting support, props, as well as setting of a comfortable room
temperature. Remove all unnecessary objects in order to free the
working space and to be able to move unhindered, especially in the
capturing area.
Lighting setup
The primary lighting setup in my studio consists of a set of strobe
lights (constant lighting would not work because models are not
perfectly still subjects, and the smallest shake or movement will
affect the sharpness of the final image). Personally, I prefer using
monolight strobe units for the following reasons: they are independent
light sources and accidental breaking of any one of them would not
influence the others; each monolight can provide a substantial light
output; they require less cabling. Depending on the image in mind,
each of the light sources can be individually set to specific power
levels and can be outfitted with light modifiers, such as softboxes,
beauty dishes, grids, color filters, etc. Reflectors can also be used
to assist in proper distribution of light in the studio and on the
subject and to achieve the desired light painting effect. I found
proportional modeling lights very helpful in previewing the light
pattern, which will be produced with flash lighting. A traditional
light meter can be used to measure the light distribution in the setup
but nowadays digital cameras provide an easier way to preview the
results of the lighting setup, substantially simplifying the task of
achieving desired lighting.
Triggering
Monolights are usually equipped with photo slaves. Therefore, if at
least one flash fires others will immediately respond in unison. If
simultaneous firing of all flashes works for your projects - like it
does in my case - then the setup is very straight-forward. You can
trigger the "leading" flash via either a wireless trigger or a
cord. If using a cord, just connect it to the flash unit closest to
you to minimize tangling and to keep it out of the camera view.
Figure 2: Photography Equipment
Cameras
For the purposes of this article, we will focus on digital
technology. Any professional-level digital photo studio
should have in its arsenal two or more cameras. Technical difficulties
do happen with even the best-in-breed cameras, and they should not be
show stoppers. My own experience taught me that having a back-up
camera is not just beneficial but can be a lifesaver.
If your priority is the ultimate image quality and not necessarily the
speed of capturing, a medium format digital camera or back would
typically be a better choice for your studio. They are slower but
produce images of superb quality. In my studio, I use a Mamiya ZD
medium format digital camera (Figure 2: Photography
Equipment).
Equipment List
645 System
- Mamiya ZD
- Mamiya 55mm f/2.8 AF
- Mamiya 80mm f/2.8 AF
- Mamiya 150mm f/3.5 AF
35mm System
6x7 System
Lighting Equipment
Printing System
Figure 3: Workstation
Computer System Tools and Utilities
Checking the camera for dust
Regardless of the format of the camera you choose to use, prior to the
photoshoot you should inspect its image sensor to determine if
cleaning is required. To do so, set a lens aperture to the highest
setting (typically 22), point the camera to a white image displayed in
full screen on a clean computer monitor, defocus the lens, and take a
picture. Review the picture on the computer monitor at 100% zoom. What
you see is what you will get in every image captured (dust specs will
appear softer with wider aperture settings). When deciding to clean or
not to clean, be aware that opening the camera body always carries a
risk of introducing additional dust specs. If you decide that cleaning
is not necessary even though some dust specs are present, still save
the dust reference image as it can be used either for faster manual
locating of dust spots in the subsequent images or for feeding into
dust removal software (some cameras have this feature built-in). If
cleaning is required, follow the manufacturer's guidelines.
Lenses
The choice of a lens is determined by the desired field of view, the
available studio space, and the nature of your project. Focal length
of the lens affects depth of field, focusing distance, and visible
proportions of the objects at various distances from the lens. Fixed
focal length lenses are generally the sharpest, while quality zooms
offer quick versatility. Speaking about quality, it is important to
realize that all lens manufacturers have their great, good, and
not-so-good lenses. Hence, it is important to know specific
performance characteristics (and weaknesses) of the lens when deciding
on using it (or even better, purchasing!). There are several great
online resources that can help you in this regard.
II. Capture
Camera settings
I recommend carrying out studio capturing with a camera set to either
manual mode or, if present, a special "X" mode, designated for
photographing with strobe lights. In either case, the shutter speed
should be set to the highest value of the sync speed supported by both
the camera and light units. Take a test image: if any part of the
frame looks darkened, it may indicate an incorrect setting of the
shutter speed as shutter itself is being captured in the image. If you
are using a wireless trigger, the darkening can also be caused by the
latency in the triggering mechanism. To troubleshoot this, trigger
with a cord.
Michael Ezra
If your project requires freezing a motion (e.g. jumps), then you
should go for strobe lights with a shorter flash duration and a camera
system with a higher sync speed. In all other cases, a more or less
standard sync speed of 1/125 of a second is sufficient. Shorter flash
duration will always lead to sharper images. But keep in mind that on
some light units shorter flash durations are achieved by reducing
their power output (less light).
After you lock the shutter speed, you can control the exposure setting
of the camera with the aperture dial. Considering that aperture
influences the depth of field, I first decide on the aperture based on
the look of the image I intend to capture and then adjust the power
setting of the strobe lights to provide a correct exposure with the
selected aperture.
A camera's LCD display can provide a quick and informative feedback on
the capturing conditions. I find the histogram to be the most
important feedback of the digital camera as it allows to analyze
exposure conditions in detail. While some cameras provide individual
histograms for R, G and B channels, the majority display the luminance
histogram, which is derived from the relationship of captured R, G and
B channels—a white balance. Thus, a correct setting of the camera's
white balance prior to capturing makes the displayed histogram meaningful
and, thus, has the direct impact on the accuracy of photographer's
judgment on exposure. In the studio workflow, I recommend to measure
and set the custom while balance for each photo session using a gray
card (follow camera-specific manufacturer's guidelines).
In addition to histogram display, some cameras are equipped with a
feature of blinking those areas of the preview in the captured image
that exceed threshold levels—those which are over- and under-exposed.
Addressing noise
The exposure settings during capture have a direct impact on an
unavoidable and thus important factor—image noise. Noise inherent to a
digital image is introduced in two stages: during the image capture
process and during image recording process.
Firstly, you can minimize the capture noise by increasing the
amount of light being captured. This can be achieved by a) increasing
the light output of the strobe lights; b) opening the aperture of the
lens to allow more light in; c) increasing duration of capture (not
really applicable when strobe lights are used). Considering that
studio environment provides full control fover the light used for
image capture this part is usually not an issue.
Michael Ezra
Secondly, you need to ensure that your camera is tuned to
measure/record the maximum information. Keeping the camera at its
lowest ISO setting will enable it to operate at the maximum of its
capability. This setting will permit the camera to capture the widest
possible range of brightness in the scene and, subsequently, record it
with the least amount of noise.
Due to specific design of the image sensors, the medium format
digital cameras are particularly advanced in capturing wide dynamic
range. The only lower-end professional DSLRs that can currently
compete with them in this territory are Fuji S3 and Fuji S5
models. This excellent wide dynamic range capability of medium format
digital cameras in the studio environment can be put to a good use
through purposeful careful overexposure of the captured images by
about 1-1.3 f-stops in order to ensure the capture of the cleanest
files possible, with noise-free shadows. Subsequently, during
development of raw images you can apply a compensating negative
exposure correction to straighten the brightness of the image files.
Image recording parameters
Photography, even digital, is all about light—capturing it and
then recording it. While previous section discussed how to optimize
the capture aspects, here I would like to say a few words about
successful image recording.
The accuracy with which captured light is recorded into a digital
file is characterized by a) the spatial resolution of the file
(measured in megapixels) and b) the precision of digital encoding of
the color and brightness of the captured signal. Loss of precision
during the recoding process leads to loss of the image data. Different
cameras offer different flexibility when it comes to image recording
parameters. My simple recommendation is to always use the full
resolution of the camera's sensor and the highest available settings
for recording color and brightness nuances. In other words, capture in
RAW format exclusively! (see Table 1)
Table 1: Overview of recommended settings for studio image capture
and recording parameters
| Setting |
Recommended Value |
| Image format |
RAW (uncompressed or with lossless compression); plus optionally small JPG preview in high compression, unless camera is slowed significantly |
| Resolution |
Maximum |
| Color space |
Widest available (irrelevant for RAW) |
| Bit depth |
Maximum, if selectable |
| ISO |
Native ISO, usually minimum value |
| Shooting mode |
Manual or "X" |
| Shutter speed |
Fixed at camera's sync speed |
| Aperture |
Set based on desired depth of field; controls exposure |
| Exposure compensation |
Off |
| Image rotation |
On |
| Sharpening |
Standard (irrelevant for RAW) |
| Image tone |
Standard (irrelevant for RAW) |
| Noise reduction |
Off |
| Allow capture without a memory card |
No |
| Image capture method |
Tethered or to memory card(s) |
Image recording
One of the important conveniences of the studio setting is that
recording of captured images can be extended to their essential
destination—a computer. Instead of recording images on memory
cards, they can be transferred directly to computer storage as they
are being captured, either wirelessly (for some camera models) or
using Firewire or USB cable connections. Some cameras, Mamiya ZD for
example, have a great feature: if writing of image data to a computer
fails, they can automatically switch to writing to a memory card
instead so images would not get lost. This is a valuable feature as
cable connections are not 100% reliable.
Capturing tethered to a computer has a number of advantages, such
as a large size accurate image preview on a calibrated computer
monitor (which can also turn into a distraction), a more detailed
image histogram, a more secure storage media, automatic naming and
proper placement of the image files, and time saving on a subsequent
bulk data transfer from the memory card to the computer
storage. Capturing to a memory card, however, has an advantage of a
completely wireless camera system (when wireless sync with strobes is
used). During my photo sessions I often practice both: I usually start
with tethered capturing and later on, when lighting is fully confirmed
and if greater mobility is required, I may switch to memory cards.
(Figure 4: Mamiya Digital
Photo Studio, tethered capturing)
Figure 4: Mamiya Digital Photo Studio, tethered capturing
Faster and reliable memory cards are certainly preferred; their
important characteristic for studio use is the ability to withstand
accidental falling on a floor, as shock can lead to data
corruption. So far I have had no problems with SanDisk Extreme III and
IV series 4 GB and 8 GB cards. Luckily the drop test has not yet been
conducted in my studio. Extreme series cards are usually packaged with
file recovery software that can be very handy in other more creative
accidents.
III. Computer system
Monitor calibration and profiling
In order to assure that the colors and brightness displayed by the
computer monitor are accurate, the monitor must be properly
calibrated. Use of the calibrated and profiled monitor is absolutely
critical at every step of the photographic workflow, starting from the
tethered image recording when images are displayed on the screen to
provide visual feedback, certainly during subsequent editing of the
images and at a later stage, while preparing them for printing. An
uncalibrated monitor will introduce major discrepancies in image data
display and will be a killer for digital workflow.
It is important to understand the difference between calibration
and profiling. Monitor calibration is a process of adjusting internal
characteristics of the monitor itself. Monitor profiling is
essentially calibration of the video card output, i.e. instructing the
card to send proper signals to a calibrated monitor. Only some
monitors on the market can be calibrated by a user. Most of the
monitors are factory calibrated, but allow adjustments of brightness,
contrast and color enabling a user to fine-tune the monitor
calibration during the profiling procedure. Most software packages
handle calibration of the monitor only within these limits, as they
are mostly designed for video card profiling.
Until a very recent upgrade to an NEC 2690WUXi LCD, I was using a
Mitsubishi 2070SB CRT analog monitor along with Gretag Macbeth Eye One
Display calibration unit. My first generation Eye One Display unit
simply stopped working in about a year. The second generation Eye One
Display 2 seems more reliable—it is still operational and provides
good calibration and profiling results. Eye One Display 2 is supported
by various monitor calibration and profiling software packages, but I
found the software that it comes with—Eye One Match—to be the most
optimal solution. Eye One Match offers a very limited support for
Display Data Chanel (DDC), which enables a fully automated software
control over the monitor settings, and, hence, all monitor adjustments
have to be made manually. Though manual process is tedious,
calibration results are quite good. One of the ways to measure the
quality of the achieved monitor calibration and profile is to evaluate
the grayscale gradient in a color-managed application (such as
Photoshop) for smoothness, neutrality, and clipping. Other third-party
calibration software packages can additionally provide a quantitative
measure of the quality of the achieved calibration result. Yet, while
trying them out I ran into compatibility issues and stayed with Eye
One Match solution.
As for a recent upgrade, I am still evaluating the SpectraView
software from NEC, which allows for fully automated monitor
calibration and profiling using DDC.
Main storage
Considering that the main storage of your computer system is
responsible for storing all image assets of your photo studio, it is
crucial that it should be able to withstand failures of individual
hard drives. If hard disks never failed on you yet, it is pure
luck—and it will eventually run out.
Michael Ezra
There is a variety of storage redundancy solutions available on
both a consumer and professional level. One of the simplest redundant
storage setups is mirroring of a drive, which is RAID 1. In such a setup
each drive has an identical copy created in real-time. The next level
with increased storage performance characteristics is RAID 5
configuration, requiring at least 3 disks. This setup can also survive
failure of any single disk, but it provides a better read performance
because stored data is stripped through multiple disks and can be read
in parallel. Initially I chose RAID 5 for organization of the main
storage in my studio, until I had a simultaneous failure of 2
disks. Luckily, I was able to recover one of them on another machine,
using specialized software, which allowed me to bring the entire RAID
5 online and create a full latest backup.
This incident may seem like a very unlikely event, until one
considers the fact that all disks in this RAID 5 array were acquired
in a single purchase from a single vendor. As a result, they all were
from the same batch and had the same manufacture date. Since they were
under basically identical use in the same RAID array, they failed on
the same date as well! Thus, if you are serious about building a
reliable storage, I highly recommend purchasing disks individually
from different vendors. This will also ensure that any possible
problems caused by shipping would not influence all disks in the same
way.
Mindful of the time wasted for those recovery efforts, I chose to
store data at an even higher level of protection, which is RAID 10. In
this configuration when 4 disks are used, failure of any 2 disks
(unless they are paired in internal RAID 0 stripe) will still not fail
the entire storage array. The very high availability of this setup
comes with a cost: it is not efficient in utilizing storage space of
the disks, with only 50% of the total space of drives being available
for usage. RAID 10 provides excellent redundancy and high performance
on both read and write operations.
As a final note on this topic, keep in mind that the most common
cause of hard disk failure is overheating. Setups with many hard disks
require reliable cooling.
IV. Organizing
Data organization
The accumulation of image data in digital workflow can be
overwhelming. Staying organized is a time saver and the only way to
achieve it is to never let the chaos get in! Data should be organized
as soon as it is being created.
Figure 5: File System Directory Structure
There is a multitude of software packages available that provide a
"user-friendly" organization of digital content. Such solutions are
typically based on introduction of an additional layer, such as a
custom database, or a catalog, specific to a particular software
package. Switching from one such solution to another would involve the
painful process of migrating this organizational data from one
proprietary format to another, which usually is not a viable
task. This imposes a forced loyalty on a photographer.
To avoid this lockup I chose to utilize the file system structure
itself as the primary means of organization of all digital content
produced in my studio. After all, file system is inherent to storing
files and what can be better than having it organized in the first
place!
The systematization and organization of photographic data becomes
easy once you identify parameters that describe the content and nature
of the image files and their collections in a meaningful
way. Pertinent to my work with studio nudes, I employ the following
hierarchy of parameters: the type of imaging (Imaging_Nudes_Studio),
subject (a particular model or a project name), date of capture,
etc. (See Figure 5 and
Table 2). It is a very simple but descriptive system, which allows for
great flexibility.
Table 2: Naming convention for RAW files
| Folder Name |
Notes |
| Imaging_Nudes_Studio_NU |
Contains all files specific to nudes shot in the
studio |
| Models FullName_UniqueAbbreviation |
Contains all Studio Nudes files for a particular
Model
Unique abbreviation constructed from model's name will be
used in naming all files created with this model. When multiple models
are shot together, the unique abbreviation is extended.
Abbreviation should be at least 3 characters long.
Example:
Jane_Doe_JDE
|
| PhotoshootDate_AlphaIndex |
Contains all Studio Nudes files for a particular
Model for a particular date of the photoshoot
Format is
YYYY-MM-DD_A Alpha index is the sequence index of the photoshoot; it
will be carried over to the filenames in this folder.
Example: 2006-01-31_A 2007-02-15_B 2008-03-21_C |
| 1 - Raw |
Contains Raw image files |
| 1.1 - InProcess |
Contains files that are being edited |
| 2 - Previews |
Contains low resolution JPG previews |
| 3 - Contact sheets |
Contains "contact sheets" generated from preview JPG's |
| 4 - Finished Works |
Contains Master files and derived works (prints, web, etc.) |
| 5 - Prints for Model |
Contains print images made specifically for a model (if any) |
| 6 - Documents_Notes |
Contains various documents related to a particular
photoshoot, such as scanned copy of a signed model release, copy of
the model's ID card proving age, scanned receipt of payment, text documents
with any special notes. Most of these documents can be consolidated
into a single PDF file. |
Naming convention for RAW files
The hierarchy of data organization travels into my file naming
convention, so that the name of each individual file is comprised of
elements representing each level of its parent directory structure. In
order to keep the filenames short, only the unique abbreviations and
indexes from the directory names are used when filenames are
constructed. In the example below, a sample filename for the RAW file
is constructed from the bolded parts only:
Imaging_Nudes_Studio_NU_John_Doe_JDE_2006-01-31_A_SequenceNumber.FileExtention
The result will be the raw files named as follows:
NU_JDE_A_001.raw,
NU_JDE_A_002.raw,
etc.
Naming convention for derived files
Development of the RAW file into a TIFF or a PSD file results in
the creation of the Master file for that particular raw file. During
photographic workflow, Master files will necessarily multiply into
image files derived for specific tasks/purposes. Storing all this
derived content in a pre-defined set of the corresponding folders from
the very beginning and following an orderly naming convention will
make it very easy to navigate the breadth of derived image data. The
method outlined in Table 3 below allows for quick file sorting and
filtering. Under this system each filename is meaningful and provides
a sufficient amount of information to understand the nature of the
file and its storage location. (See Table 3)
Table 3: Naming convention for derived files
| File Type |
Description |
Naming Convention |
| Master |
The retouched image file created from the RAW
file. Usually TIFF or PSD. |
RAWFILENAME_[V-versionNumber]_MASTER.TIFF or
RAWFILENAME_[V-versionNumber]_MASTER.PSD
[V-versionNumber] can be optionally used to specify a particular Version of the Master file. If version number is used in the Master filename, it should be carried in the same format through all files derived from it, so the chain is never broken.
Example:
NU_JDE_A_001_MASTER.TIFF Or NU_JDE_A_001_V-01_MASTER.TIFF
|
| Preview |
A low resolution preview image of the raw
file. JPG format. |
RAWFILENAME_Preview.JPG
Example:
NU_JDE_A_Preview.JPG |
| Contact Sheet |
JPG image or a multi-page PDF document
consolidating preview images along with their file names and possibly
additional image information. |
Imaging_Type_
ModelNameAbbreviation_
PhotoshootSequence_
ContactSheet_
SequenceNumber
Example:
NU_JDE_A_ContactSheet_01.JPG
or
NU_JDE_A_ContactSheet.PDF
|
Naming of all subsequent file types is based on the name of the Master file.
| Prints |
Files created for prints of specific size. |
MASTERFILENAME_PRINT_S-widthxheight-DPI-dpi_[COLOR/BW]_EL-EditionLimit
Example NU_JDE_A_V-01_PRINT_S-16x20_DPI-720_BW_EL-55 or
NU_JDE_A_V-01_PRINT_S-16x20_DPI-720_COLOR_EL-55 |
| Web Image |
|
MASTERFILENAME_WEB-[L,M,S, T]_[COLOR/BW] Where L,
M and S correspond to Large, medium, small and thumbnail size.
Another approach may be to use image width (or height) in
pixels to indicate the size of the web image:
MASTERFILENAME_WEB-800px_[COLOR/BW]
Example
NU_JDE_A_V-01_WEB-L_BW
NU_JDE_A_V-01_WEB-800px_BW
|
| Any Other Type |
|
File names for other types of image files may be
constructed following the simple schema described above.
|
If a number of derived files for some RAW image becomes
particularly large, you can create a special subfolder named after that
RAW file, place it under the corresponding "4 - Finished works"
folder, and move all corresponding Master and derived files there.
Hint: to enforce uniqueness of abbreviations used in naming the
directories and files, one could follow a simple procedure. File
system itself has a restriction on allowing only unique filenames in
any single directory. Create a special directory,
"Used_Unique_Abbreviations." Every time that you need to use a new
abbreviation, create there a new bogus Text file (right-click, select
"New/Text Document") with a desired abbreviation as its filename. The
operating system will automatically verify this new abbreviation
against the existing list of previously created files. If no errors
occur and filename is allowed, the abbreviation is unique. Do not
delete this new file as its filename becomes a part of the used
abbreviations list.
Why search? Filter!
Adapting to the described file naming scheme allows fast and easy
location of folders containing any particular image. When names given
to directories and files are meaningful, navigation through the
digital content becomes straightforward. You would no longer need to
search for files blindly, because you will simply know where they are.
As many of my Master files contain various adjustment layers and are
stored in PSD format, the choice of an application capable of
displaying previews of these and other derivative files correctly is
pretty much limited to Adobe products, and Adobe Bridge, packaged
along with Photoshop CS2 and CS3, can do the job. The filtering
interface of Bridge has a lot left to be desired, but it does work.
An important configuration setting of Adobe Bridge is enabling
usage of the distributed cache. This effectively instructs Bridge to
put a pair of files (Adobe Bridge Cache.bc and Adobe Bridge Cache.bct)
into each and every folder that it visited during searching. These
files contain cached information specific to the image files stored in
respective folders. This setting is quite beneficial since the cached
files can travel along with the corresponding image files during
backup, restore, and move operations and will stay available for
immediate utilization by Adobe Bridge.
Once I had an unfortunate accident while updating Meta information
for a Master image file using the Bridge application. The unexpected
crash in the application caused corruption of the image file and
rendered it unusable. Unfortunately, I attempted this before that
particular file has been backed up. That was a hard lesson and since
then I adhere to the policy to never update Meta information writable
into the image file itself for any of the original or derived image
files, with exception of easily re-creatable content, such as
previews, contactsheets, and web images.
In my studio workflow, I use Adobe Bridge to get a quick and
convenient overview for the body of work stored in various image
formats. Reaping more benefits from the chosen file naming scheme, the
filter criteria in my Bridge collections is primarily based on the
meaningful parts of image filenames, such as abbreviation of the
model's name, "MASTER", "PRINT", print sizes, "Preview", "WEB",
etc.
V. Editing
Silkypix: creation of the Master files
Figure 6: SilkyPix RAW Converter Software
There is a great variety of software packages available to handle the
critical task of the Raw conversion. Primary differences between them
are summarized below:
- Specifics in interpretation of the raw data, which results in
different quality of the final result
- Set of included image processing tools, which can be applied
within, right after and post of the raw conversion process
- Workflow integration options
Upon comparing various raw conversion packages, I decided to use
SilkyPix for the majority of the raw files. SilkyPix answered my
demands for the three aspects listed above very well. There are rare
exceptions when the magic of SilkyPix alone cannot rescue the shot
(e.g. extraction of the most extreme dynamic range from the highlights
of the raw data). In these cases, I turn to Adobe Camera Raw or try
other solutions.
The power of SilkyPix lies in the high quality interpolation
algorithm of the RAW data and user-selectable precision control
(Demosaic Sharpness slider). A 100% setting will force extraction of
the full resolution of data that seems possible. Because of heavy
machinery employed in the raw processing algorithm of SilkyPix,
conversion process is not a fast one. For a faster generation of the
small JPG previews I use a 10% setting. However, when ultimate
resolution of the Master file is desired, it is an indispensable tool.
SilkyPix offers non-destructive editing of image files in RAW and
other image formats. Supported color space of input images is limited
to sRGB and aRGB. Editing information for each file is stored in a
subdirectory "SILKYPIX_DS," which gets automatically created in the
folder where the edited file is located. (see Figure 6: SilkyPix RAW
Converter Software)
The batch renaming feature in SilkyPix is very extensive and
quick. When using batch renaming in SilkyPix all files in
"SILKYPIX_DS" folder also get automatically renamed. However, renaming
of images outside of SilkyPix may break the link between them and the
files of their SilkyPix adjustments.
SilkyPix allows creating user presets for every type of image
adjustment as well as user presets spanning multiple types of image
adjustments; the latter ones are called "tastes." An example of a
useful "taste" is a combination of Color Space, Sharpness, Tonal
adjustments and white balance. Adjustments can be copied from one
image to another with a simple copy-paste operation. Pasting can be
partial so that only some of the copied adjustments would get
pasted. This simple feature greatly speeds up RAW processing workflow.
SilkyPix: Preparatory Workflow
Here is a quick walk through of my SilkyPix preparatory workflow for
studio nudes. First, pick a representative RAW file of the photo
session and apply the following rough adjustments:
- set the white balance to a setting measured from an image of the
gray card shot in the beginning of the photo session
- fine-tune exposure
- adjust tone (contrast, midtones and gamma, apply curves)
- apply minor selective color enhancements
- set Demosaic sharp setting to 10%
Michael Ezra
Copy these adjusted settings (Ctrl-C). Select all raw files from
the photo session and paste copied settings (Ctrl-V). Open each raw
file and apply individual adjustments to exposure and any other
settings necessary. Correct image rotation and cropping. Delete
unnecessary images as you find them (you can also mark them for
deletion by pressing F6 to re-view your selections later prior to mass
deletion). When done, select all raw files and mark them for batch
processing to generate Previews. Batch-develop all raw files into JPG
format, sRGB Colorspace, in a size you prefer (I suggest to use
resolution size of your monitor) with suffix "_Preview." When done,
select the first raw file, set Demosaic sharp to 100% and output
Colorspace to adobeRGB, and copy these settings (Ctrl-C). Select all
raw files. Right-click and select "Paste partial development
parameters." Check "Development (Demosaic sharp/Resolution
Plus/Colorspace)." Press "Execute." Select menu "Option" (Alt-O) /
Option (O) / Generate thumbnails of all scenes. This will generate all
thumbnails to allow faster image browsing in SilkyPix. Now you are at
the state when raw files are available for further final
fine-tuning. Since cropping/rotation is already applied, comparison of
various images for selection of the best one is simplified (JPG
preview images can also be used for this purpose).
Editing of Master files: combining SilkyPix and Photoshop
SilkyPix has a true 16-bit processing engine under the hood. The
most popular professional photo editing application, Photoshop,
surprisingly handles only up to 15 bits of the image data. Losing that
16th bit means that an entire HALF of the tonal information is ignored
by Photoshop when the image file is opened and is subsequently
discarded once it is saved. Considering the importance of the tonal
information in creation of fine art images, I recommend using the full
16-bit power of the raw conversion process to create a full tonal base
for the desired look of the Master image file while keeping an overall
contrast of the image low and avoiding clipping by staying away from
pure whites and blacks. The tonal and color adjustments in Photoshop
should be applied only in adjustment layers.
Table 4 provides a quick overview of editing tasks that can be
performed in RAW conversion process and in post-production
manipulation of the master files.
Table 4: Creation and editing of Master files
| Procedure/Setting |
Raw Conversion |
Editing Master File |
| Recommended Tool |
SilkyPix |
Adobe Photoshop |
| Output Format |
16-bit TIFF, uncompressed |
16-bit TIFF, uncompressed or ZIP
compression
PSD format if saved with adjustment layers.
Optionally PSD files can be saved in maximum compatibility mode in
which file also contains a flattened layer representing a merge of all
layers in the file. This will increase the PSD file size.
If
adjustment layers do not contain masks, then masks can be deleted to
minimize file size. |
| Exposure Correction |
Apply as needed. Avoid clipping. |
Fine-tune if needed.
Global exposure
variations in the image can also be corrected using curve adjustment
layers applied in luminosity mode with gradient-filled
masks.
In difficult cases, raw conversion outputs made with
various exposure settings can be merged with masking.
Setting
white and blank points (using a final curves adjustment layer) should
be used only in a very last step of editing. Avoid clipping. Do not
merge final curve adjustment layer with the background image
layer. Image layer should remain at lower contrast, so it will be
available for further manipulation if necessary. |
| White Balance |
Fine tune as desired. |
In difficult cases, raw conversion outputs made
with various WB settings can be merged with masking (should not apply
to studio setting). |
| Demosaic Sharp, Superresolution |
100%. This is equivalent to capture sharpening but
without any artifacts.
10% for generation of JPG previews. |
N/A |
| Resolution |
Full |
Full |
| Color Space |
Widest possible. Adobe RGB. |
Editing space: Prophoto RGB, Gray Gamma 2.2. Blend
RGB colors using gamma 1.00 |
| Histogram |
Always carefully observe. |
Always carefully observe. |
| Rotation/Cropping |
Apply in SilkyPix as it performs rotation without
loss of resolution due to simultaneous enlargement of the file while
rotating. |
Fine-tune what was not fully handled in raw
conversion. It is better to perform image rotation only once to avoid
softening. |
| Lens Corrections |
Correct chromatic aberrations, vignetting, minor
distortion. |
Correct anything that was not fully handled in raw
conversion. |
| Color Mode |
As desired. Do not over-saturate. |
|
| BW Conversion |
Do not use, it is better to have master file in
color for any possible future use. |
Apply using adjustment layers. Channel Mixer is
generally sufficient for studio nudes as image colors are not
pronounced. Keep color master as a background layer. |
| Selective Color Adjustment |
As desired. Do not over-saturate. Avoid
posterization. |
Use Selective Color, Hue/Saturation adjustment
layers in various blending modes. Use masks when needed. |
| Curves |
As desired. Keep contrast lower than needed for
the final output (prints, etc). Avoid clipping. |
Apply in adjustment layers. Use masks if
needed. |
| Gamma/Contrast |
As desired. Keep contrast lower than needed for
the final output (prints, etc). Avoid clipping. |
Apply in adjustment layers (via levels or
curves). Use masks if needed.
Color-based contrast
enhancement can be applied using Hue/Saturation adjustment layer in
luminosity blend mode. |
| Sharpness |
All settings at 0. Do not apply in raw conversion.
In SilkyPix make sure to turn off Unsharp Mask filter in the
final output (development) window.
"Pure Detail" sharpening can
be applied for JPG previews. |
Master Files: very minor sharpening to emphasize
selective content and compensate for texture loss due to
editing.
Minor Unsharp Mask filter—apply in luminosity mode
with large radius for local contrast enhancement; apply through masks
in separate layer when needed. |
| Noise Reduction |
As desired. Multiple conversions can be made with
and without NR for further merging/masking. |
As needed; use Noise Reduction with suppression of
color and luminosity noise applied in separate layer in luminosity blend
mode; use masks. |
| Moire (false color (FC) adjustment) |
As desired. Multiple conversions can be made with
and without FC for further merging/masking. |
As needed; use Noise Reduction with suppression of
color noise applied in separate layer in color blend mode; use
masks. |
Retouching: Photoshop
I find a pressure sensitive pen and a tablet to be an indispensable
tool for fine retouching of digital images. They provide an
incomparable control over the retouching process; no mouse can replace
it. I am currenlty using a Wacom Intuos3 9x12" tablet and am
extremely happy with it. I perform all editing of Master files in
Adobe Photoshop, which provides a full support for these pressure
sensitive tools.
Photoshop's Healing Brush is an excellent tool for an extensive
localized retouching that studio-nudes images often require. It allows
for touching up imperfections on model's skin while preserving the
texture. The quality of texture preservation depends on the selected
brush radius (in comparison to the characteristic size of the
texture), the hardness setting of the brush, and the extent to which
the brush is being used.
Dodge & Burn brushes are very instrumental for correcting unevenness
of the skin (such as cellulite) without any loss of texture. Their use
is also very effective for localized enhancement of dimensional
appearance of a subject's form.
Brightness non-uniformities throughout the frame can be corrected
using Curves adjustment layers with gradient-filled masks.
Below are a few illustrations of before and after comparisons using
various techniques.
Example Image 1: Localized Exposure Correction
|
Example Image 2: Skin Retouching using the Healing Brush
|
Example Image 3: Using Healing Brush and Cloning Patches
|
Example Image 4: Using Healing Brush and Cloning Patches
|
Conversion to black and white
There are numerous ways to perform a conversion of a color image to
its black and white version because there are numerous ways to present
variations of color and luminance in terms of variation of brightness
in the grayscale. In my usual studio setup there is very limited color
information in the photographic scene, hence, the conversion to black
and white in most cases can be performed using a Channel Mixer
adjustment layer. In some cases I also add either Hue-Saturation or
a Selective Color adjustment layer in lightness blend mode for better
transformation results. The final step in black and white conversion
is Curves adjustment layer, which is used for fine-tuning the contrast
and setting the black and white points of the image. It is important
to observe the histogram of the image to avoid tonal clipping at all
stages of the adjustments.
Although most of my sculptural nude works are printed in black and
white, I do preserve the originally captured color information in the
Master files, saved in this case in PSD format, along with all
adjustment layers used for black and white conversion. When masks of
the adjustment layers are entirely white, they can be deleted to
decrease the size of the PSD file. Black and white adjustment layers
can be grouped into a Layer Set and reused for conversion of
similarly shot images from the same photo session—Photoshop allows
drag-and-drop operation for layer sets between open image files.
VI. Exporting
Once Master files are created, retouched and adjusted, we can use
them to derive images targeted for a specific output. The most common
derivations are images that will get presented on the Internet and
images that will be printed.
Web images
Creation of web images can be standardized to produce them in a
desired size and framing preferences by employing Photoshop actions. A
sample action for creating web images can be downloaded from my web
site at the following link: www.michaelezra.com/downloads/actions/WebActions.atn
Figure 7: Creation of Action in Adobe Photoshop
If you would like to create your own action, simply record it by
going through all steps that you would like to be covered when
creating a web image, and then play that action on a flattened Master
file from which you would like to create a web image. (Figure 7: Creation of Action in
Photoshop)
To create a Photoshop action, select Actions window (Alt-F9 for PC),
click on a small triangle in the upper right corner as shown in figure
below and select "New Action" menu; give a name to a new
action. Action recording is started automatically, as indicated by a
"Start" button (red circle) in the toolbar on the bottom of the action
window. Execute all image processing steps that you would like to be
recorded into this action and press "Stop" button (square) in action
window toolbar when finished. The action is automatically saved when
recording is stopped. To execute the action in order to repeat all
recorded steps on another image, open the desired image and press the
"Play" button (triangle) in the action window toolbar. Always test the new
action on a test image first; specifically, be careful with "Save
Image" steps in the action to avoid accidental overwriting of the
original image.
A few notes concerning web images:
Example Image 5: Sample Web Image
- Web images should be created in sRGB color space or using the
"Save for Web" feature of Photoshop. This will ensure the most consistent
display of the web image on a variety of computer monitors of the web
users. If the image is strictly black and white, then it can also be
prepared in Grayscale Gamma 2.2 mode.
- Placement of copyright notice may be specific to each individual
image. This step in the Photoshop action should be enabled with a
manual override. Simply toggle the "dialog on" option next to the
check mark for the step where copyright notice gets moved. Action will
pause at this step and wait until you finish positioning the copyright
notice. After you are done, action will continue.
- When downsizing images for web, use Bicubic or Bicubic Sharper
interpolation method. Downsampling works better when carried out in
multiple iterations. Usually, I first downsample using the Bicubic
method to a size 1/2 of the final web image, sharpen the image, and in
the second iteration downsample to the final size.
- Sharpen image using a duplicate layer in luminosity mode with
blend mode targeting only midtones. Smart Sharpen filter can be used
with great results. Flatten image when done. (Example Image 5: Sample Web
Image)
Images for printing
There are a lot of nuances and details that can be covered within this
topic. In this overview article I will only point out a few essential
aspects important for creation of high quality images targeted for
printing.
I use 24-inch wide Epson Stylus 7800 printer with Epson K3 Ultrachrome
inks for printing limited editions of the sculptural studio
nudes. The quality of print output and its longevity in combination of
these inks with archival inkjet paper makes this setup an excellent
choice for producing high quality fine art prints.
Preparation of the print image is always specifically tuned to a
particular printing setup. The factors to be considered include the
printer, inks (if it is an inkjet printer), the paper, the driver
settings, and, optionally, the lighting conditions in which prints
will be viewed.
Resolution
It is important to know the native resolution of the printer,
which is going to be used. Epson printers, for example, support
resolutions of 360 and 720 dpi. When an Epson driver is used for
printing, it will interpolate the image to one of these resolution
settings, unless the image is already prepared in either 360 or 720
dpi. Interpolation quality of the generic printer drivers is horrible
and results in severe artifacts, clearly noticeable as jagged lines in
the diagonal patterns of the image. This is why it is important to
prepare a file in a specific size, matching the resolution expectation
of the printer driver. The higher resolution settings usually
mentioned in the driver (1440 and 2880 dpi) usually confuse the users
as they have an entirely different meaning. These numbers refer to the
accuracy at which each individual pixels' content gets rendered in
mixing of various inks. Yet the pixels themselves are placed on paper
at the printer's native "pixel" resolutions. Higher resolution setting
in the driver will result in more precise rendering of each pixel and
consequently—finer reproduction quality of tonal transitions in
the prints.
There are many possible ways to obtain a quality interpolation of
the images. Unfortunately there is simply no single method that I
could recommend because image interpolation is very content
specific. In my practice, I usually interpolate the same image using
various methods and blend the result using Photoshop layers and
masks. This allows me to maintain a high level of detail and texture
where needed and smoothness in open areas of the image. Master image
should be flattened prior to interpolation.
Sharpening
Example Image 6: Using Smart Sharpen Filter for Image Sharpening
The final sharpening of the image should only take place when it
has been interpolated to the final size. Smart Sharpen filter can
provide good results but is extremely time consuming on large
images. SilkyPix "pure details" sharpening method can be applied to
TIFF images with excellent results and much faster than Smart Sharpen
filter in Photoshop. I usually blend sharpened and not sharpened
images together using masks to have an additional control on what gets
sharpened and to what extent. (Example Image 6: Using Smart
Sharpen Filter for Image Sharpening
Color
The interpolation of the image to the target size and the following
sharpening should be carried out while the image is in the editing
color space (Prophoto, Adobe RGB or Gray Gamma 2.2).
It is important to understand that similar to the monitor & video
card color profile that interprets image data for viewing, each
printing setup has its own color profile that is used to interpret
image data for printing.
The correct reproduction of the intended color depends on
performing a correct interpretation of image data tuned specifically
for the printing setup to be used. This interpretation is carried out
through a conversion of the image to the output color profile. This
color profile is created for each particular printing setup and is
specific to driver settings, inks, paper and viewing lighting
conditions being used.
For studio nudes I use the advanced black and white printing
capability of the Epson driver. This allows me to print image data in
Grayscale (Gray Gamma 2.2) mode instead of creating the custom color
profiles for black and white printing. The puzzle of black and white
printing gets solved by carefully selecting a finely-tuned combination
of driver settings for media type, dpi setting and ink density for
each inkjet paper used. This does require some experimenting, and in
my case efforts were well rewarded with very fine and consistent
quality print output. Advanced black and white printing of the Epson
driver allows creation of an extremely archival output due to
prioritized use of most archival black, light black and light-light
black pigments.
I usually maintain a document for each of the images that I prepare
for printing. These documents contain information on every significant
setting used. This helps to ensure consistent printing of further
editions of each of the images at a later time.
VII. Archiving/Backing up
Backup
In addition to having a highly redundant main storage I would
strongly recommend to have a few backups of the digital photographic
content. Table 5 outlines the suggested approach for backup strategy.
Table 5: Backup strategy
| Backup Type |
Schedule |
Media/Notes |
| On-site |
Tightly coupled with progression of workflow +
weekly
Maintain backup log to help restore |
Magnetic - Attached External Storage (single hard
drive units or RAID 1) which is always turned off unless is used for
backup or restore.
Optical - Archival quality DVD. |
| Off-site |
Weekly, semi-monthly, monthly
Maintain
backup log to help restore |
Magnetic or optical - External Storage (single
hard drive units or RAID 1) transported off-site after
backup.
Magnetic or optical - Off-site storage accessible via
network.
Magnetic or optical - Archival-quality DVD (use a
brand different from one used for on-site storage. |
The digital photography workflow results in frequently occurring
changes to the derived digital content: new master files get created
and transformed into new print and web images all the time. From the
storage point of view it means that the same organized directory
structure is populated with more and more additional data. Hence, the
most convenient form of backup for organized directory structure
presented in this workflow would be an update backup. In this mode the
backup target is maintained as a complete copy of the source,
maintaining the same exact organized directory structure. This
provides the advantage of a full understanding of the structure and
content of the backups and to have a full control of the restore
process as well, not relying on interpretation of the hidden backup
structure forced by any specific backup software package.
In update backup mode the new files are copied over, changed files
are overwritten with the latest changes and files that are deleted
from the source (the main storage) are also deleted from the
backup. The update backup is very fast due to the fact that unmodified
files are skipped, thus the total amount of data being copied is
limited to updates only.
Michael Ezra
My search for the most suitable software package capable of backing up
large amounts of photographic data using update backup mode landed on
a very lightweight freeware tool, called SameDir. Originally I
invested in a Nero package, which claimed to be able to support update
backup mode. It never really worked correctly in update mode and the
performance of Nero's BackitUp application is on the slow
side. The advantage of SameDir is that it is very fast and so far is
reliable. SameDir also offers data compression options, which I decided
not to use as compression significantly slows the process.
Nero Express, on the other hand, offers excellent tools for writing
backups on DVDs. If you decide to compress files prior backing them
up, I would recommend using a WinRar application. Backup of RAW files
should be carried in a disk-at-once mode, as these backups are
final. Backup of the derived content can be carried using the
multi-session mode to allow adding of the files as they get created.
As backup DVDs get created, their sheer number can easily get
overwhelming. It is important to keep them organized to be able to
quickly locate the correct disk with a specific file. For this purpose
I wrote a custom freeware application - Smart Disk Catalogue. It is a
simple to use utility program, which allows creating a comprehensively
searchable catalogue of backup DVDs. Smart Disk Catalogue can be
downloaded from my web site at www.michaelezra.com.
For backing up the operating system drive I would recommend Acronis
TrueImage Home. It supports a large variety of RAID controllers and if
your system is installed on RAID 0, this is definitely the program of
choice. Nero also offers system drive restoration, but that feature
is primitive and is not compatible with RAID controllers.
Restore
Should a problem with the main storage occur, or some files on the
main storage get accidentally overwritten, deleted or corrupted, a
restore from backup is a sure help. Restoring from well organized
backups is not a complicated
process. Considering the fact that the directory structure of backups is
the exact copy of the source in the main storage, the restore process
becomes a straight-forward copy of the required folders and files.
Versioning
Considering that on-site and off-site backups are carried on
separate schedules, differences in their content may offer different
versions of your photographic data. Versioning can also be
accommodated with DVD-based backups, carried at various times, thus
storing different versions of your data. Smart Disk Catalogue
application can help you search through the content of your entire DVD
library and find files with similar or the same names across all
DVDs. The date and time stamp of the files listed in search results
should allow you to locate the correct version easily.
Conclusion
I hope that the information provided in this article will be
helpful to streamline your photographic process. The digital age brings
the benefits of advanced technologies, efficient and detailed
systematization and easier automation of the photographer's
workflow. Careful and thorough analysis and adjustment of each and
every step of your workflow will allow you to increase its efficiency,
solve technical challenges, and free up your mind for creative
artistic exploration of the photographic medium. After all, even
though the technical side of the photographic process is fun by
itself, what ultimately matters is the result that comes out of
it!
More
About the Author

Michael Ezra is a New York-based photographer
specializing in fine art sculptural nudes as well as fine art
landscape photography. Born in 1972 in Tbilisi, the capital of the
former Soviet Republic of Georgia, he studied painting from his early
years. He graduated Tbilisi State University with degrees in
theoretical physics and painting, and continued to intertwine a
scientific approach with an artistic expression ever since. In 1993,
Michael Ezra moved to United States and began his physics studies in
the field of medical imaging. For the next seven years, through his
move to New York City and career change to software architecture and
development, complex surrealistic painting remained his main channel
of artistic self-expression. In 2000, inspired by Michelangelo
sculptures, Michael Ezra turned to photography and began developing
his concept of black-and-white studio sculptural nudes. In his easily
recognizable style, he created a wide body of original sculptural
works, which is sometimes referred to as a "reference catalogue of
poses." In 2004, he extended his portfolio to include fine art
landscape photography. Michael Ezra's professional background in
imaging and in software development enabled him to make an easy
transition to the world of digital photography and provided a solid
foundation for comprehensive understanding of existing technologies.
More »
Example Fine Art Images from Michael's Gallery
Michael Ezra
|
Michael Ezra
|
Michael Ezra
|
Michael Ezra
|
Michael Ezra
|
Michael Ezra
|
Original text ©2008 Michael
Ezra, screen shots, tables, and photography ©2008 by Michael Ezra.
Article created July 2008
Add a comment