Welcome to Photo.net: A Community of Photographers

Home > Travel > Berlin and Prague > Dachau Concentration Camp

Dachau Concentration Camp

a photo essay by Philip Greenspun; created 1999

Townhouses whose backyard is the Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany If you're so inclined, it is possible to live in a brand-new condo built just a few meters from the walls and barbed wire of the Dachau Concentration Camp. The camp would literally be your back yard. You could tell visitors "Keep an eye on the enormously tall sign for the McDonald's restaurant. Turn left at the Arbeit Macht Frei gate. If you come to the Krematorium or the blood trench where the Soviet POWs were shot, you've gone too far."

Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Dachau was Germany's first concentration camp, started in 1933 because the prisons were overflowing with people the government didn't like. They didn't have enough money to just build more prisons the way we do in our War on Drugs, so the Nazis built work camps like Dachau. Dachau is distinctive because it was here that SS personnel (Eichmann, Hess) trained for work in newer camps such as Auschwitz. Pastor Martin Niemöller, who initially supported the Nazis, ended up here in 1938, whereupon he famously noted that

Als die Nazis die Kommunisten holten,
habe ich geschwiegen; ich war ja kein Kommunist.
Als sie die Sozialdemokraten einsperrten,
habe ich geschwiegen; ich war ja kein Sozialdemokrat.
Als sie die Gewerkschafter holten,
habe ich geschwiegen; ich war ja kein Gewerkschafter.
Als sie die Juden holten,
habe ich geschwiegen; ich war ja kein Jude.
Als sie mich holten, gab es keinen mehr,
der protestieren konnte.

-- Der Weg ins Freie, Martin Niemöller (F.M. Hellbach, Stuttgart, 1946)

When the Nazis arrested the Communists,
I said nothing; after all, I was not a Communist.
When they locked up the Social Democrats,
I said nothing; after all, I was not a Social Democrat.
When they arrested the trade unionists,
I said nothing; after all, I was not a trade unionist.
When they arrested the Jews,
I said nothing; after all, I was not a Jew.
When they arrested me, there was no longer anyone who could protest.

-- translated by Bob Berkovitz (
rbbrook@worldnet.att.net)

VW Golf parked next to Krematorium. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Dachau is huge. It would take about an hour just to walk around all of the grounds. Approximately 30,000 prisoners (1,173 of them German) were living there upon liberation in 1945. The site is thoroughly reminiscent of a huge public high school, assuming your public school had an original Arbeit Macht Frei gate, a gas chamber (never used), or a Krematorium. The original barracks had to be torn down in 1965 when the camp was made into a memorial; they were too badly decayed.

The camp headquarters is now a museum. To a Cantabrigian, the most familiar figure will be Dr. Siegmund Rascher. He did gruesome medical experiments involving freezing people in cold water or air, then trying to warm them up with hot water (this would allegedly help the German air force). He also subjected people to high altitude simulations until they died. Was he cruel? Did he hate non-Aryans? No. He just wanted to get his PhD. He kept submitting research reports to Nazi-controlled universities in an attempt to boost his credential portfolio. He would have graduated with distinction had not his infertile older wife been arrested for stealing babies.

The grounds

Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

The famous gate

Arbeit Macht Frei. Gate to Dachau Concentration Camp, just outside Munich, Germany Arbeit Macht Frei. Gate to Dachau Concentration Camp, just outside Munich, Germany Arbeit Macht Frei. Gate to Dachau Concentration Camp, just outside Munich, Germany

Reconstructed Barracks

Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Barracks. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

The Main Building

Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

The Krematorium

Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Krematorium. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Krematorium. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Krematorium. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Krematorium. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

Behind the Krematorium

Pistol Range for Execution. Dachau Concentration Camp, just outside Munich, Germany Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

The Jewish Memorial

Jewish Memorial. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

Jewish Memorial gate. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany Jewish Memorial interior. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

The Carmelites

Carmelite Monastery. Dachau Concentration Camp. Just outside Munich, Germany

Practical

The medieval town of Dachau is now a suburb of Munich and the S-Bahn will whisk you there in a few minutes. I went straight from the Munich airport. At 170 kph, my Turkish cab driver simply followed the signs to Stuttgart and then turned off at the Dachau exit. As we approached the town of Dachau, there were signs directing us to the camp (a huge McDonald's sign is also a good landmark).

The camp seems to be open from 9-5 every day except Mondays.

Readers' Comments


Add a comment



Frank Wortner , April 06, 1999; 09:29 A.M.

The saddest part is how little people seem to have learned in the passing years. Genocide still happens. People still look upon others as less worthy, less human, and then they act on their worst impulses.

We cannot bring back those who suffered and perished at places like this, but we should at least honor their memory by resolving never to allow tradgedies like this to be repeated again. The camp at Dachau and the other preserved death camps are not fitting memorials; a fitting memorial would be a world free of this sort of hatred. How sad that we haven't built it yet.

Brian England , April 14, 1999; 10:07 A.M.

The six of us, traveling through Europe after a magical stay in Greece, decided to make Munich our last major stop before heading home. Dachau came the second day. To say it was a horrible place would be to state the obvious, like saying the grass is green, or the sky is blue. This day the sky was gray and full. We walked around the grounds, among the shells of building, through the never-used gas chamber. As we were preparing to leave, the clouds broke apart, and the most brillant rays of light came streaming through the clouds. Everyone there stopped where they were and looked, the warmth hitting their faces. It was beautiful. My friend Jenny stopped crying. We all looked at each other, American children so far removed from the war and what took place where we were standing, and had a single, unified thought...the Germans couldn't take everything away from them. At least they had the sun that could sometimes look like this.

Ken Mayer , April 28, 1999; 12:07 A.M.

A resonance, from my trip to the Holocaust Museum in D.C., years ago. (On my 30th birthday with my girlfriend, no less.) It is almost at the end (you start at the top of the building and work you way down), past the shoes, the glasses, and the gold fillings. There's a gallery of photos taken in a small shtetl by a local photographer. You've seen some more of these photos before, one story up. There's a placard that says all of the residents were taken to Auschwitz and none of them survived. Then you look up. The gallery is built like a chimney, open to the sky. And you are moved, how can you avoid it. The life of a town, the wives, the couples, the merchants, the football team, the dreams; gone up in smoke.

Hector Javkin , May 06, 1999; 08:33 A.M.

Thank you for the essay and especially the pictures, they are very powerful. When travel takes me close enough, I've made it a point to visit the sites related to history's outrages: the Holocaust Museum in Jerusalem, the Peace Park in Hiroshima, the memorial to the siege of Leningrad, the Pearl Harbor Memorial. When in Argentina, I always march at least once with the mothers of the disappeared at Plaza de Mayo. I attended a conference in Munich, and took a subway every day at a station which had signs to Dachau. It would have taken maybe half an hour on the train. Despite having lost family to concentration camps (in Nazi-run Europe and in Argentina), I couldn't bring myself to go.

Bruce J Leventhal , May 06, 1999; 10:17 A.M.

Phil, This was a nicely done photo essay... thanks. Last summer my wife & I went to Dachau to do a photo essay. I was armed with my Hasselblad and a bag full of film, and was ready for the shoot. The minute I walked through the gate, I cramped up. I shot 6 pictures of barbed wire & endless fields, and couldn't take another shot. We solemnly walked throughout the camp until we reached the mass burial graves of the unknown dead. At that time a Polish gentleman (about 75 years old) walked up to me and asked if I was Jewish. I replied that I was and he then asked why I was not saying a prayer for the dead.... well, although I'm not the crying type, the tears began to flow. He then showed me his rainbow card with the date that he was released from the concentration camp. As if that was not enough, he told me that he was Catholic, watched many friends die, and then did the "viahafta" in Hebrew for me at the grave site. To this day, I think about that old survivor of Dachau and ponder how humanity has not been able to resolve conflicts based simply on race, religion, and ethnicity.

Thanks for reminding me of these powerful memmories. Bruce Leventhal

Starla Wilson , May 12, 1999; 03:04 P.M.

To graduate from high school we have to do a senior project. Because I have always been interested in the Holocaust, I narrowed the subject down and focused on Dachau. Never before have I felt the horrer like I felkt when I began perusing the materials and looking at the pictures. After the paper I did my physical project and built a model of Dachau. As someone noted earlier I never realized how meticulous everything is. They prportioned everything just so. When it was complete I cried at the small scale of hell I had just built. My heart goes out to each and everyone of them.

harry lister , June 10, 1999; 05:55 P.M.

I have visited Dachau twice--in 1985, just after graduating from college, and again in 1994 while traveling through Germany with my wife. During the second visit (late September) it was raw, gray and rainy--weather that only helped to deepen the discomfort one feels walking over ground where such unspeakable acts were carried out. Just as we were preparing to leave, an old gentleman approached us and asked us if we were Americans. We said that we were, and he proceeded to tell us his story, how he was in the camp when it was liberated by American and Spanish forces. He said that, rather than return home or move to Israel as many of his contemporaries had, he chose to make his home in Dachau. He undertook to learn both English and Spanish and visits the camp each day, searching for Americans and Spaniards to thank--and to put a real face to the horror that transpired there.

Jamie McCarthy , June 21, 1999; 07:42 P.M.

An excellent and perceptive photo essay.

A correction or two, if you don't mind. I'm not aware of Adolf Eichmann or Rudolf Hess having trained at Dachau - maybe Eichmann was there, but he was with the Gestapo through the 30s and it doesn't seem likely. Rudolf Höss got some early training there as a drill instructor and so on, then went on to Auschwitz; that's probably who you meant.

Also, strangely, Rascher and his wife were arrested not for kidnapping but for trying to "pass off as biologically their own two children they had merely taken into their home. That this could be made an offense punishable by death is yet another incredible aspect of the Nazi regime." (Nazi Mass Murder, Yale University Press, 1993, p. 203).

A site I webmaster has detailed information on the Dachau gas chambers, by the way.

Donald Bellunduno , July 04, 1999; 09:31 A.M.

9 years ago as a university student, I visited the Buchenwald concentration camp just outside of Weimar in what was then East Germany. In the center of Weimar, there is a statue to two of Germany's greatest contributors to literature and poetry: Goethe and Schiller. Through their contributions, Weimar became a respected name throughout Germany during the times they lived. That horror such as what occurred at Buchenwald (like Dachau) could have happened side by side with a place like the city of Weimar should be a lesson to Humanity. Just because we believe we are noble in deed, does not mean that our actions are always noble as well.

Humans all too easily look the other way when an impending danger lurking near by touches a neighbor, but does not immediately touch them. Just as the people of Weimar...couldn't believe what was going on at Buchenwald, most Germans offered the same horror when they found out what was happening at similar camps throughout Germany. It was the classic..."I didn't know," response. They also "didn't know" or were "not aware" of all their Jewish freinds and colleagues being carted off by squads of SS men in the early thirties either. People they'd worked with side by side and called...brother, or fellow worker, or simply faithful colleague. Perhaps they didn't know, or perhaps...they didn't want to know.

If a person or people can learn to devalue one, they can easily devalue...a million. Or, six million. This is the lesson the camps should teach future generations to guard against. People often ask how tragedies such as a Holocaust can occurr. Human selfishness leading to Human indifference, which leads to an inability for us to generate basic Human emotions to our fellow human beings: love and protection. For, if we could generate such feelings, regardless of the case, tragedies like this Holocaust and all the other Holcausts would not have existed in the first place. The person who finds a way to link Humanity together so that we finally stop hating each other because of color skin, political beliefs, etc, should win more than the Nobel Prize. That person should be exalted as the single greatest contributor to Mankind. Period.

Arnold V Becker , July 19, 1999; 12:25 A.M.

I visited Dachau on a cold February day in 1967 and never have felt so cold. It was not the physical cold of the day for it was quite warm for February in Southern Germany. It was knowing the kind of inhunanity that man had carried out in this camp and the others. How can man kill men, women, and children. People who have done nothing wrong except to be of the wrong religion or race, or in the wrong place at the wrong time. The recent events in the Balkans prove that this can happen again unless we as a human race work hard at trying to ensure that it does not. We all, as individuals and groups, have to work together to make sure that this does not happen again anywhere in the world.

An American visitor to hell.

Arnie

Bob -- , July 28, 1999; 09:24 P.M.

I visited Dachau while in the US Army in 1968. The thing I remember most vividly is that there was a poster (photograph) of Hitler in the Museum, and someone had scratched the eyes out with their fingernails. bob peters

Kevin Sharkness , August 08, 1999; 03:13 A.M.

big red one.

Kevin

Dave Koch , August 19, 1999; 11:11 P.M.

I, too, visited this camp. Your pictures brought back some of the feeling- the horror, dread, sorrow and pain I experienced there. They are very good, but hardly a substitute for the real thing. In Germany, school childrn are REQUIRED to tour this camp. This is a very good thing. It is a horrible thing to see. And that is precisly why you should go.

Never Again...

P. Neil Ralley , August 25, 1999; 12:19 P.M.

Excellent treatment of a grim subject. I too visited Dachau a few years back and your essay and the other comments pretty much sum it up. One thing that especially struck me was just how close it is to the centre of Munich. Too many times I have heard and read how the ordinary "person in the street" in Germany was unaware of what was being carried out until very late in the war. The fact that Dachau was functioning from the 30's in such close proximity to a major city to me means that more people were cogniscent than cared to admit it....

Neil Ralley, August 1999

Robert Bowman , September 12, 1999; 03:43 P.M.

I visited Dachau in late April, 1995, nearly 50 years to the day after its liberation. I met a man there who was among those liberated on that day. He was 18 when imprisoned, just a boy from Poland. He had vowed never to return to Germany, but now, living in Canada, he had wanted to visit to mark the day of his liberation. He described the last days in the camp; aircraft overhead, shooting inside and outside. Tears poured down his cheeks as he pointed to the wall where the American soldiers first entered the camp.

William McBride , September 22, 1999; 06:28 A.M.

We were told on our tour of Dachau that "we (the locals)didn't know anything about it" and the crematorium "was never used" as you report above. After the tour an elderly tourist from Chicago literally got on a soapbox, showed us his Auchwitz tattoo, and told us "they are lying, I am here to tell the truth- Their parents worked here, and many died in the crematorium." I have since seen a TV documentary on Dachau culled from Nazi films. The exact same crematorium pictured above and which I have seen with my own eyes was piled high with ashes and bodies were hanging from the meat hooks along the beams. They ARE lying.

Gary Parsons , October 11, 1999; 11:36 A.M.

I've heard the words "never again", since I was a young boy. It is my sincere hope that things like the Holocaust would never happen again, but I'm afraid that it will happen and maybe with more prejudice. Students of Biblical prophecy know that a time of trouble to exceed all before it is forecasted. My question is how could mankind be led to this again? For those who will accept it,"it is because of spiritual wickedness in high places". Yes, there are forces of evil at work, just as there were in Nazi Germany, and the results will be even more vile than before. Without the attention and concentration of mankind on cutting off this disease, it will fester in Government chambers and in the minds of those who would be religious leaders, and before you know it, we will be in the middle of global turmoil and another attempt at genocide. It is definitely something to think about!!

David Orlinoff , October 12, 1999; 03:56 P.M.

In 1985 I was in Germany on a business trip and decided to visit Dachau. I drove over in my rental car, and was held up by a traffic jam--2 shepherds, 3 dogs, and about 1000 sheep were crossing the road. When I finally got to the site, I discovered that starting earlier that year the camp was closed on Mondays, just like all the other "museums" in Germany. I stood there marveling at the irony that the walls were keeping me *out*.

The following year I visited on another day of the week and was impressed by the number of German students being brought there on their required field trips. Let's hope they learned something...let's hope we learned something.

thomas m. lewis , January 22, 2000; 02:38 A.M.

I have pictures of Dachau in 1945, however my pictures show the rooms with blood stained walls where the SS threw starved men, women and children. I also have the blast furnices where they cremated the bodies of people murdered by gas. The stack of the furnice is somewhat taller in 45, but the building is the same. My photos are black and white and were taken the day the camp was liberated.

Javed Akhtar , February 17, 2000; 09:33 P.M.

Similar to one of the previous readers' comments, I too had an encounter with a Dachau survivor.

Last summer, my gifrlriend and I took a backpacking trip through Europe. After an amazing two months bumming around Greece, Italy, Switzerland, France, Austria, and Prague, we finally arrived in Munich. Our visit to Dachau was deeply disturbing but a valuable experience nonetheless. Our new friend, Oskar (the Dachau survivor) had brought along photographs of the camp from 1945. The blood stained walls, the filthy bodies piled on top of each other, the heartless prison guards... it was all too much. I have never felt such powerful emotion. I couldn't bring myself to photograph anything on the site. The next day, Oskar showed up at the hostel I was staying at. He dropped off a photographic copy of one of his photographs of the living quarters. This was the photograph that induced such an intense emotional response in me the previous day. The photograph is now in my photo album from that trip, and serves as a constant reminder of how things can get out of hand if the wrong people have power. I think Dachau should be a mandatory stop for anyone visiting Europe.

Also, when I was in Munich, I was sitting on a park bench having lunch with my girlfriend. An elderly German man on a bike stopped to rest on the bench. We started talking to him, and he told us stories about WWII. The most vivid memory he shared with us was about when Jews would be hiding in their basements from the Gestapo. He would often walk around at night and discreetly give bread and water to the Jewish families. Any time that he would venture outside of Germany, people would resent his presence, just because he was German.

Never again.

Lovisa Olehdll , May 02, 2000; 01:35 P.M.

A place like the Dachau Memorial Site shouldn't and probably doesn't leave anyone untouched. Going there is a big project, and not something you should do in half an hour. You'll need several hours to try and understand something of what it was like to be a prisoner there.

A practical piece of advice for those who don't speak German is to buy a book that contains the texts in the museum translated to English or to take a guided tour. Otherwise you'll miss a lot in the museum.

I would like to say that it's not true when we tell ourselves "this will never happen again". Because it has happened. Look at Bosnia. Look at Rwanda. Not much has changed in the way we humans think.

One think that hit me while contemplating the historical background in the museum was that Hitlers part in the things that happened isn't as decisive as many people have tried to make it. Don't get me wrong, I'm not in any way trying to defend that horribel murderer. I'm just saying that the Nazi ides began long before he entered the stage, preparing way for him, welcoming him. He couldn't have done it alone. It was not because of one person that six million jews were killed. In fact, it wasn't because of one nation either. It was because of the sefishness of humanity.

Therefore it is very hard for me to say "never again". For as much as I wish it could happen, I doubt humanity has or will change. But that doesn't mean struggling for a change is useless. Because without anyone fighting the evil forces during World War I, Nazism wouldn't have been stopped at all.

What I'm saying is: fight for saving the values of this world but don't live in the past. Don't think of Nazism as the last time it happened.

love Lovisa, 16

Susan Johns , June 01, 2000; 12:37 P.M.

The horror that occurred in these places will never be forgotten. Or have we already forgotten one of the first things the Nazi Party did for its citizens? They registered their guns and then, at a later date, they confiscated all the guns from the citizens. A de-armed citizenship has no way to fight against a government that has gone aray. Sixty years later, in countries around the world, we are being asked to register our guns for our own safety. I wonder what the Nazi party told its citizes when they called for registration. I highly doubt they told them what they had in mind for Jews and anyone who spoke out against them. Maybe the Nazi government told the people they should register their guns for their own safety.

Randy Olson , August 01, 2000; 12:12 A.M.

While stationed in Germany in 1973 I attended the Octoberfest in Munich and on our way home we visited Dachau. After viewing these pictures, even after 25 years I can remember the same thing most of the visitors say, Munich was festive and colorful, while the day at Dachau was gray and overcast and all my memories of it are still in black and white. Just like your photos.

Jacob Messing , August 10, 2000; 10:33 A.M.

This is one of the vilest essays I have ever read. Philip, I find that your sentences carry inferernces that deny the true evil of the Nazi's. Sentences like "Dachau was . . . started . .. because the prisons were overflowing . . .," makes it sound like the Nazi's had a simple prison over population problem. Dachau was built because the Nazi's were rounding up all Jews in a plan to rid Germany of Jewish people. When you write, "...with people the government didn't like," it makes the Jews sound like criminals or some other problem of society when in fact there was a national propaganda campaign to blame Germany's economic troubles on Jews. Just what are you saying when you write, "They didn't have enough money to just build more prisons the way we do in our War on Drugs, so the Nazis built work camps like Dachau?" If they didn't have money for prisons, how did they have money for death camps? This makes it sound like the Nazi's tried to keep the Jews alive but they just couldn't afford to. This is like saying some student couldn't afford to go to college, so he became a hitman to pay for the bills. And on a personal note, comparing the extermination of European Jews to the War on Drugs is in very poor taste. You wrote that Dr. Rascher didn't really hate Jews, he was just bolstering his credentials in pursuit of a Ph.D. First of all, you can't tell me that the man who tortured, mamed, and killed hundreds of human beings was not cruel and just after his Ph.D. He was there not because he was the brightest in his field, but because he was one of the only ones who would was sick enough to do it. The truth of the matter is that there were many people who rebeled against the Nazi's because they knew that it was evil. There is a huge monument in Yad Vashem in Jerusalem dedicated to the bravery of those righteous gentiles. The Holocaust was so evil that it is nearly impossible to comprehend. You can't rationalize actions of individuals within an evil system to place blame on the Nazi regime. You can't rationalize the actions of the Nazi's as carrying out orders. I know you are a busy man, but you should rethink your analysis of Dachau and Dr. Rascher and rewrite your article.

harriet wichin , September 18, 2000; 03:11 P.M.

i was very interested in this photo essay. my attention was immediately drawn to the photo of the condos just over the wall. from 1990-94 i shot a documentary film at dachau and auschwitz entitled SILENT WITNESS, exactly about this topic of "how do we preserve memory?" "how has the site been transformed over time?" i, too, was taken aback by the cars parked near the crematorium. SILENT WITNESS introduces the viewer to both sites, Dachau and Auschwitz, and has in-depth interviews with people who live and work on the sites: Carmelite Nuns at Dachau (and Plotzensee, in Berlin), a Jewish survivor who acts as tour guide in Dachau, a survivor at Auschwitz who returned after the war and never left, living out his days as a tour guide and director of part of the museum, and others. the film was produced by wichin-york film in 1994, copyright in Canada. please contact hwichin@sympatico.ca for more information.

Jessica Sharp , October 09, 2000; 07:05 P.M.

Hi, my name is Jessica and I'm 16 years old. This past summer I got the opportunity to go to Europe on a band trip. Germany was my last stop of my 16 days of traveling. Before we got the Dachau the band director warned us about what we were about to see, but nothing could prepare us. We got to walk around the grounds for about 45 minutes and then we watched a movie about the camp. It was so shocking to realize that those people were being murdered right where I had walked a few minutes earlier. I couldn't help but cry. While I walked infront of the memorial I couldn't help but notice a group of Jewish people crying. That really got to me. I felt so sad. Now I'm doing a report and presentation for my Global Studies class in school to show everyone just how horrible the "death" camps were. I pray that this never happens again. My heart goes out to everyone who lost a loved one during the war.

kylie marie ooyendyk , March 26, 2001; 08:44 P.M.

hi, i would just like to say that i think it dan right terrible for what those german soldiers did to thoise people, i mean they even did it to young kids. i do believe that maybe about 40% of the german soldiers didnt really want to torcher those people but they were forced to. i know that if i were there i would have wanted to be one of the first ones to be killed than to be torchered and put up with seeing people walk to the gas chambers, etc. i also think that we should (the whole world) have atleast 2 minutes silence once a year like they do for remberance day to pay respect to the people of were murdered in the Dachua Concentration Camp.

Eileen Carman , April 22, 2001; 11:29 P.M.

As a child of six I went to visit Dachau with my parents in 1956 while my Father was stationed not far from Munich at KaufBuren(SP). When I found your site and viewed the pictures, the old horror returned along with the sad and empty feeling I suffered while visiting. My heart was torn then and is torn now.

I think the pictures of the Krematorium were what brought the horror back to my mind. I remember the tour guide telling us the usage of each building and each site in Dachau. When I burst into to tears as a child, it was from true heart wrenching agony. I still feel the terror. Eileen Carman, American Service Child

Tom Benton , May 14, 2001; 11:13 P.M.

In a recent tour of Germany, I went to the Dachau concentration camp. On the train from Munich my friends and I were amazed at how nice it was outside. When we got to Dachau, it was raining, and dreary. I was glad it was that way, cause I didn't want it to be sunny and nice out, after I got there. It is one thing to read about what the Nazi's did to the Jews, but it's another to stand in the courtyard where they all stood for role call, or walk into the "shower" rooms, and knowing that at one time, there was a scared, naked, person standing right where I was, that was about to die, just because of there religion. I hope, and pray that the Holocaust will be a model to the world, to never, EVER let this happen again. This site does the Dachau camp justice in explaining what happened there, and what is there today.

Steven Swart , May 17, 2001; 04:54 A.M.

This is an amazing page. Everything including the reader comments add valuable commentary.

It is terrifying how the line of rationale for mistreatment of people can morph from seemingly innocuous "prison overflow" to the systematic genocide of an entire race of people. I have never been to Dachau, but I have been to the American South where monsters like Nathan Bedford Forrest are still honored by statues, memorials and parks. It worries me that such men can be honored where so many kind and friendly people live. In the Southwest there are prison "tent cities" for drug offenders and other non-violent 'criminals'. I think that is the point the essayist here is trying to make: Dachau did not START as an internment camp for Jews. It started as a dumping ground for the unwanted, the political troublemakers, etc.

Most of the comments posted here reflect horror and shock over what "the wrong people" in power did. Sadly, I think everyone can be the "wrong people" in the wrong situation, and that only a determination to bravely stand against our own internal prejudices, our desire to find blame for our misfortunes, and our internal longing to elevate ourselves by debasing others can prevent the holocausts that pop up all over the world every year (Boznia, Sierra Leone) from happening. In a way, when we go to Dachau (in person or on the web) and grimly shake our head at the horror that the "wrong people" perpetrated, we are doing the same thing - thinking that somehow these people who did these horrible things were somehow wired differently... they were not. They simply gave in to temptations of fear, disdain and illegitimate pride.

May we never succumb to those forces again.

Greg Westbrook , May 30, 2001; 04:06 P.M.

These are very sobering pictures. I have some of my own that my Dad brought back from WWII. I don't know their exact origin but he said he confiscated them from an SS guard that they had taken prisoner. They can be viewed starting here:

http://www.ionet.net/~gregwest/page18.html

There were a couple of others that were just too gruesome for me to scan and put out on my site.

Zap Trax , June 14, 2001; 12:16 A.M.

The saddest place I have ever been. My mind did not record any color only black and white. I also find the commentary upsetting. Only trying to get his PhD? And old Tim McV was only trying to make a point. When we ratioalize this kind of inhuman behavior we create the moral environment that let's us standby as Bosnia happens, as Chechnya happens, as Rawanda happens, as... We don't need more guns; we need to tolerate, no we need to embrace and celebrate what is different in the other people who share the planet. We need to shoot pictures not people!

Jeroen Wenting , July 23, 2001; 09:51 A.M.

A very good piece on one of the saddest parts of European history. To the person who says Philip is trying to gloss over the cruelties of the place, he is not.
Dachau did indeed start out as a prisoncamp, and never really was a destructioncamp like Auschwitz (though many thousands died there).
Dachau was a prison and a labourcamp built for the same purpose as many camps that were put up in that era all over Europe and possibly the rest of the world. Originally it was designed to hold only people with short sentences.
Only later was it converted for use as a camp to supply slavelabour to the industry, and were conditions reduced to those of camps like Bergen Belsen which were meant to squeeze work out of people until they dropped dead. This is seen in the fact that originally there was no crematorium or gaschamber, and that the main gaschamber was not used a lot.
Terrible things happened there, as they did all over Europe and Asia during worldwar 2. Bavaria was the homesoil for the NSDAP (Nazi party) which was originally a local party in Munich. Bavaria had a large problem with political dissidents during the Weimar republic, and could not house them all in prisons (Hitler was one of these, having been arested after taking part in a failed revolution. During his time in prison he wrote Mein Kampf). Dachau was meant for them originally, and used as such until the extermination program for Jews became too large for the main destructioncamps around 1943. At that time it and other camps were converted to serve as waystations (and endstations for some) on the way to Auschwitz and the other large destruction camps further east.

It's been a long time since I was in Dachau, but seeing these pictures still chills the mind. The Germans have learned (though not all of them, maybe), but the rest of the world may not.
Forgotten are the victims of Stalin and Mao yet they were greater in number. The victims of Pol Pot and the homicides in Africa are hardly remembered at all.

Michael Oryl , August 10, 2001; 11:10 A.M.

I have just returned from the camp, only minutes ago (I live in Munich now). In general I found the camp to be quite a disappointment. It was too clean. Too tidy, well groomed. The vast majority of the photos in the museum showed images the type of which the nazi's would have shown to the world early on in the 30s when they were trying to downplay the stories that were beginning to circulate in the world regarding the camps. It drew no emotion from me nor my mother, and it did not seem to have any real effect on the other visitors. I hope that some of the other camps are better preserved....

Mihkel Kraav , August 14, 2001; 10:04 A.M.

Concentration camps in Germany existed about 60 years ago and of course it was awful. But we know about it so much only because Germans themselves make these memorials and pay contributions. On the same time tens of millions of people were sent to Siberia. This continued for decades and decades and in fact it did not ended even now. Lots of Chechnyans were murdered in Russian concentration camps just because they had too dark skin. My father was 4 year old when he was sent to Siberia. His dad died in Russian concentration camp.

Everyone knows names Dachau or Auschwitz but you can hardly find pictures of these Russian camps. Aleksander Solzhenitsen writes that there were 84 concentration camps even in 1920. There were 15 millions of farmers sent to the Siberia between 1929-30. Nobody knows exact number of concentration camps in Siberia but it was in thousands. Average number of prisoners in one camp was again in thousands...

I remember that even in 1980-s we had to choose our words very carefully because otherwise we could find ourselves in Russian concentration camp. Camps were reality 10-20 years ago.

I’d like to see pictures of these camps in Internet as well but probably this wish is senseless. Internet is just like picture taken with fish-eye…

Matthew Schillerberg , September 19, 2001; 03:09 P.M.

It is incredibly depressing that these monuments to horror have not worked to prevent similar holocausts. Rhwanda, Yugoslavia, The Kurdish people, Cambodia, etc. All of these events have occured since WWII and with minimal outcry from the international community. One would of hoped that the world would unite in outrage at these acts of genocide. In fact, the news media has hardly covered these some of these horrific events.

As an American, I think that the United States should own up to its own genocidal history and create its own monument to the horror that the US government inflicted on the Native Americans. This was an act of genocide that is in many ways just as horrible and unspeakable but hardly mentioned in history books.

One wonders what it will take before the world can unite in peace...

Ivan Abrams , September 22, 2001; 10:08 A.M.

I came to Dachau in the summer of 1971, after a year spent living and working in Jerusalem. I was 24 years old, and in my youth believed that the horrors of the past were behind us. My time in Israel imbued me with a certain arrogance at having demonstrated by my very existence the folly of genocide. I viewed Dachau with appropriate contempt, though it thoroughly frightened me.

Thirty years later, my innocence has been swept away. I've lived for the past ten years along the US border with Mexico. I've witnessed the struggle of immigrants seeking only redemption being persecuted by a US government that claims to be just but is bereft of compassion. I've practiced law for a quarter century and seen the War on Drugs become a War on People. I read daily of starvation, disease, war, of the Israeli-Palestinian horrors and wonder whether Dachau is more the lingering symbol of contemporary inhumanity than it is a relic from the past.

This year, so far, some 75 refugees have died crossing the Arizona desert in their journey from Mexico. They were channeled to their death by the US Border Patrol, which has fortified the easier passages. Our government continues to repress the seekers of freedom and opportunity. We have little reason to be smug about Dachau--the horror it represents continues to be among us.

Robert Gordon , December 27, 2001; 07:11 P.M.

Viewers may want to check out Michael Kenna's new book of photographs on the concentration camps. All proceeds go to a non-profit group.

Robert Gordon

Juan Porras , February 13, 2002; 07:07 P.M.

As always I look at anything related with the catastrophe of WWII, I feel something revolting inside me. The work is well done, to my point of view, since it touches inside.

I was surprised to read a mention to spaniard troops in allied armies. There where many spanish volunteers in both Soviet and British armies ( I think also in American) that fought for the chance of freeing Spain from Fascist dictatorship (of course there also were troops sent by Franco to aid Hitler in Russia) . Also where instrumental in building up the french resistance, as many monuments there conmemorate. 75.000 spaniards died in German Concentration camps. Some two hundred thousands survived in workcamps. One million Gipsies died in German concentration camps and almost no one remembers them now.

My point is: We must remember. But We must remember them all and many times that is forgotten. Jews where the largest number, but main victim was humanity as a whole.

I have to agree with what MsRothstein said. Also point that Palestinians are both muslim and christian, 30% of Palestinians are christians.

Don Sutherland , February 13, 2002; 09:28 P.M.

It is my wish that by your helping preserve through images memories of the darkest side of human nature, that each person and each generation will gain the enlightenment and understanding necessary to restrain this cruel side of human nature. If each person can refuse to surrender to the impulses of hate and rather recognize the immense beauty that can be found in people whomever they might be, wherever they might live, and whatever their Faith, traditions, or culture might be, a better world for all of humanity will be within reach. It is up to each one of us to answer this basic call to our fellow human being. It is within each of our power to heed this responsibility. By doing so, the cumulative effect for the better becomes overwhelming and invincible. Don World Images

Michelle Morgan , March 01, 2002; 05:05 A.M.

I am currently serving in the military as a National Guard member and visited Dachua for the first time last year. As I walked through the gates of Dachau Concentration Camp I was aware of the history but really had no idea what to expect. It was frightening and very sobering to read the narratives, see the facilities and walk through the camp. To see the inhumane actions of others on people that were undeserving of such evil. I broke away from the group so I could soak in what people had done to other peole. Questions kept running through my mind as I walked. Aren't we all God's children? How could people become so cruel and hateful to the point that they would slaughter other people. Each one of us are created in God's image. Each one unique and perfectly made. Even after seeing and feeling the gut wrenching horror and still after all this time smelling the remains of the bodies that were burnt, the truth of the matter is hard to digest. I left the camp slowly in uwe of what I had seen. The demons in that place were still so thick and heavy, I could honestly feel a few on me, clinging to me as I walked around. The time had come to leave. My mind was so full from what I had just seen that I did not take the time to pray the demons off of me. I just wanted to get away from the camp. But as I road in the car away from Dachua I could definately feel something on me -- it felt heavy, dark, and it was hardening my heart. I tried to forget about it but realized very quickly after being hateful to a friend of mine the next day that I needed to pray these demons off of me. Once a person enters into a place that has been infested with evil, they jsut can't shake the demons. Only by the name of Jesus will they leave. The bible says they shutter at the name of Jesus. Demons can not stand to be in His pressence and must flee. I took some time alone and asked the Lord to help me and to take the demons away from me. And He did it. The damage I created with my friend was done and it caused a dent in our friendship but Praise God I was free from the demons that had attached themselves to me. If you are wanting to be free from the demons in your life, I want to share with you that there is a God that is greater than the hate and fear the enemy portrays. Satan hates God and everything He stands for: Truth, Love, Mercy, Forgiveness. The bible says we do not fight with flesh and blood but with the powers of darkness. It also says the enemy (Satan) walks the earth looking for those he can devour and destroy. But there is power in the name of Jesus. Power to overcome the enemy and all his ways. Walk in truth, walk with the Lord and see your life change and the demons fall off of you. He is an awesome God who gives hope and life to those that seek his face. It's simple...The Bible is the word of God and it is TRUTH. Read it and see. Michelle 3-1-02

Brian Hamill , June 27, 2002; 07:17 A.M.

Interesting essay. Although I haven't been to Dachau, I have visited a very similar camp just north of Berlin. That was a moving experience, and I find that I have to agree with others on this page who think your article trivialises the horrible crimes which took place in concentration camps in Germany and Poland.<P> "Turn left at McDonalds" sounds completely ridiculous in a context of this magnitude.

todd hedrick , July 21, 2002; 09:24 P.M.

My name is Todd Hedrick. I am the proud grandson of Bernell "Bernie" Hedrick. He was the jeep driver for the Company commander, E co.,42nd "RAINBOW" division of the 222nd infantry regiment. My grandfather,Bernell,was one of the brave soldiers of the 42nd to first liberate Dachau. I once asked him about Dachau. His face lost all expression and stared straight ahead into space. He shook his head slightly and closed his eyes as if to erase the picture from his thoughts. Grandpa never answered and I never asked again.

Daniel -- , August 12, 2002; 06:40 P.M.

No one who has made any comment saw Dachau as I did, four years after the war, 1949 to be exact. They did not clean it up, but many unmentionables were lying around. In Munich according to the German pieces of garbage I spoke to, NO ONE knew that the concentration camp was there. "We never knew about it, or smelt it". No one ever worked there. Who carried out the executions?. They should find out the children & granchildren of the SS & other executioners, and send them to the ovens (alive).

Mark Davies , September 03, 2002; 02:40 A.M.

My father liked jazz and rock music; I love classical music. I suppose I am saying that my father is not responsible for my actions, and I am not responsible for my father's actions. I do not think that revenge (it cannot be called much less than that) on decendants of those who were engaged in a conflict some 60 years ago would solve any problems. Rather, it would lead to more conflict. As a soldier who has served overseas in two areas of conflict, I can assure Danny that it is much better to have peace and cooperation than war and disagreement. I do believe those who committed the cromes should be punnished, but not those who were not involved.

Lovely pictures, lets not dwell on the past too much. Lets look forward to a better future.

John Stark , January 04, 2004; 09:28 P.M.

Just recently the Holocaust museum in Terre Haute Indiana was burned to the ground. Here is a link to one story http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,103430,00.html

Back in 1972 I was at Dachau with my parents. I was 12 and it was a lot different than what the photos above show. It's much more sterile now, possibly due the fact that the German Govt requires the children to go there now. Even in 1972 some tried to say it never happened.

Gabrielle Greenthaner , January 16, 2004; 02:25 P.M.

My father was stationed in Darmstadt, Germany in the early '80s and he took our family to Dachau one summer for "the tour". I was only eight years old or so, but I remember it as if it were yesterday. The pictures on this site are replicas of what has been burned into my mind all of these years. I commend your photographic study and I respect your efforts at representing the truth. The chills I felt as a child feel the same now.

Glynn Harnell , February 03, 2004; 07:39 A.M.

Judging by the comments above, and what they say about the authors of those comments, there is quite enough reason to believe that genocide on the scale it has occured throughout the Twentieth Centuary will continue to occur around the globe. There were comments by compassionate people and from people whose attitude suggests that they would be in black uniforms if the times were different (Daniel & Peter??). In some of the comments there must have been hatred just dripping onto their keyboards.

I spent my 41st birthday, as a lone Australian wandering around Dachau trying to take in the enormity of the crimes perpetrated there and around Europe during the Second World War. While not Jewish, I felt a great deal of empathy with the Jewish people at the Memorial at Dachau. I grew up in a Christian family and nearly all my early heroes were Jews, King David, John the Baptist, all the disciples except Judas, of course, and many others. I was taught that they were the Chosen People, but that they blew it when they did not accept Christ. Their loss, but I still view them as my brothers and sisters. I still sometimes view the video I took then as a reminder to myself that evil is rampant on this Earth.

The Good Book tells us that there will be wars and rumours of wars right up until the Second Coming of Jesus. This world will not know peace until that time. "When men shall say peace and safety, then shall sudden destruction come." All we can do is to follow God and try to live our lives as we understand God wants us to live them. I cannot understand why any religion would think that God wants one part of His creation to kill another part of it, whether they are Jews, Moslems, Hindus, Buddists or Christians (Protestant or Catholic). After all, isn't it God's world to judge and punish as He sees fit. Let Him handle any punishment!

These Memorials at Dachau and others places should stay in place while time lasts, so that, at least the decent people will see what has happened and should not happen again.

May the souls of all the victims rest in peace.

Glynn

Robert Brower , September 05, 2005; 11:34 A.M.

I suggest interested persons should read the Antholgy of Poetry by Carolyn Forche Titled "AGAINST FORGETTING" a Twentieth Century Poetry of Witness.

Enrique LaRoche , September 19, 2005; 02:36 A.M.

Alas the Nazis did not reserve their horror for the Jewish alone. Humans are all special.

The tragic Irony is the way the Arab and Palaestinian are looked upon by modern Israelis.

PISKARIOVSKOYE MEMORIAL CEMETERY

At this sobering place one can truly understand the scale of tragedy that this city (then called Leningrad) lived through during the Second World War (the 900-day Siege of Leningrad). For over 2 and a half years the Nazis kept Leningrad under siege, but its heroic defenders, both soldiers and civilians, did not surrender. In St. Petersburg we take pride in the fact that during almost 300 years of the city's history enemy forces have never taken the city.

Hundreds of thousands of people died in the city (mostly of cold and starvation) during the siege. About half a million of them, including 420 thousand civilians, are buried in the cemetery's 186 mass graves. The slightly raised mounds are marked by year and a long alley leads the visitor to a monument with a statue of the Motherland, portrayed as a grieving woman. Many of St Petersburg families come to the cemetery once or twice a year to bring flowers and pay tribute to the city's defenders, perhaps to members of their own family, who died during the Siege, which the Russians call Blokada.

Near the entrance there is an eternal flame, where everyone stops insilent mourning and two pavilions, with an exhibit of photographs that need no captions. During summer time Russians drop coins into the little ponds and the money goes for maintenance.

Location: Prospekt Nepokorionnykh.

Michael Lehrman , October 21, 2005; 12:59 P.M.

When I visited Dachau in 1973, I was stationed in Turkey for the U.S. Air Force. I had family that had perished at the camp.

As a 20 year old serviceman, an American and a Jew, I felt compelled to see the site. Yet, every time I raised my camera to take a photograph, I found myself unwilling to press the shutter. At that time, I did not understand why.

Now, 32 years later, I am grateful for the photos of this collection.

Regards,

Mike Lehrman

Jeffrey Engel , September 25, 2006; 12:37 A.M.

According to most mainstream historians, including prolific author Michael Shermer, who works with the Simon Wiesenthal center, and is a noted skeptic and debunker of these Holocaust "revisionists" (ie, people who don't believe the Holocaust happened, or believe it somehow was not "as bad as they claim it to be), Dachaus was *not* a so-called "death camp". SURE, people died there... from malnutrition or overworking. This happened in POW camps as well. The point being that there can be photos of dead people stacked like cordwood, and yet this does not indicate that thousands or hundreds of thousands died like this (like they did at Auschwitz) at Dachau. Many people WANT to remember Dachau as a death camp. However, if we are going to battle the Holocaust Revisionists like Zundel and the like, we MUST be truthful and honest about our recollections and what we actually know. And what we actually know is that Dachau was not a death camp like Auschwitz was (and plenty of others). When we become emotional and call it a death camp, it gives FUEL to the Holocaust Revisionists because all they have to do then is pull up the official papers of research and study by the US military, the German military, the German government, the UN, the Israeli researchers, etc. etc. that indicate it wasn't. And this lets them gloat. Be objective, and be strong with the truth, and we will remember the Holocaust as it really did happen, and the naysayers will whither away. However, get emotional, view hearsay as fact, and this fuels those bastards and influences the ignorant.

BTW, I don't want my comments to take away the sobering qualities of your photos, Philip. I was moved to tears looking at them. I'm a "2nd generation" post-war German (moved her when I was young in the early '70s), but for all intents and purposes American now. My mother used to tell me every now and then how horrible it was after the War, but the stories she relayed from my Grandmother.. the stuff they saw... it was worse. I'm glad to have grown up understanding and fighting against Man's inhumanity to Man. This is why I was so depressed when the 1990s rolled around and Bosnians were getting slaughtered, and then 1994 hits us with the Rwandan genocide.. and we're debated what the definition of genocide really is????

We have forsaken all the precedents we set forth in the Nuremburg Trials. When we tried those Nazis and sentenced them to death, we were telling everyone: look, you may be a government official, and you're simply doing what your boss told you, but there are laws ABOVE domestic boundaries.

Where is that oversight today? Do we Americans care? I'm a social liberal (fiscal conservative a bit though, I must admit) but where are all the bleeding hearts marching in teh street against what's going on in Africa today? Indonesia? How come we don't care?

Well, your photos are one small step to making us care. Thanks for reminding me, Philip. We have to be hit in the face every now and then, and this is a good tool: photography

nick hoelscher , January 20, 2007; 03:32 P.M.

most of the photos you show now are much different than what dachau looked like in 1998 but , i'm sure the feelings of people who see it for the first time are chilling to say the least . "forgive but don't forget, "

Leslie Green , March 06, 2007; 11:59 P.M.

My father was a prisoner at Dachau. He is still alive. He was 18 years old when he first stepped off the cattle car at Auschwitz after a three day journey without food or water. That was the last time he saw his parents. He was taken to a slave labor camp near Dachau where he was put to work building train tracks for the Germans. The German SS officers were cruel and sadistic. My father tells a story of being forced to spend a night sleeping in a large building where they kept the dead bodies until they had time to bury or burn them. This was punishment for putting on shoes that did not belong to him. He was once thrown into a pit of feces and forced to stand there for hours. Finally, as the American army approaced the Germans emptied the camp and packed them onto trains to Dachau. It was only through incredible luck that he managed to stay alive until the camp was liberated. By then he had typhus and was so ill that he was delerious. Actually, he says that may have saved him. He could not eat, so the Americans hooked him up to an IV. Many other prisioners, thrilled to see food for the first time in years drank whole milk and ate rich foods with abandon. Their stomachs could not handle the food and many died in excrutiating pain. After liberation he went back to his samll town in Slovakia, where his family had been farmers for 3 generations. Their belongings had been taken by the local priest who was living with my fathers furniture, eating off of their dishes. My father was lucky and was able to find a sponsor that brought him to the US. His cousin was not so lucky. Having survived Dachua and the work camps, he married a fellow prisioner. They returned to their town with their newborn child to try to start life again, only to be murdered by the local peasants, who were afraid that the Jew was coming back to take his land away from them.

Eric Perkins , March 24, 2007; 09:54 A.M.

When I was stationed in Darmstadt, Germany, I had a chance to go see this camp. It was a very nice day, nice and sunny. It was also eerie to see the camp, with knowing its past connection. Walking around the camp grounds really put into perspective of what really went on there. The terrible things that one human being can do to another. The experience is one that I will never forget. Looking at the gas chamber, although never used, gave me the feeling like what it was like at other camps that did use such lengths to kill another fellow man. While leaving the camp I couldn't help think that, we still allow mass killings go on today. I am serving in Iraq, and it boggles the mind that many people don't support the war here, but I feel that if we didn't do something then the former ?President? Suddam would still be killing a lot of his on people. My Great Grandfather and Uncle help liberate three camps. They couldn?t allow the Nazis to continue to kill innocent people and we can?t let it happen either.

Thank you, SPC Perkins, Eric United States Army

Larry Reno , April 02, 2007; 07:26 P.M.

I was stationed at Dachau Kaserne in 1956-7 with the 287th Field Artillery Battalion. This was before the museum was established and we kept the part of the camp closed off where the gas chamber building, the crematorium and the execution ground was located. If the girl above toured those buildings at age 6 in 1956, I may have been the "tour guide" as we did permit access and give tours of those areas to VIPs and visiting officers and their families. We gave a tour to Kirk Douglas, Adolph Menjou and other actors from the cast of Stanley Kubrick's excellent film "Paths of Glory" filmed at nearby Schleissheim Palace. The barracks where the the prisoners had been held were used to hose displaced persons from East Germany, Czechoslovakia, etc. They would have their physical exams, receive medicines and be trained to go out into the West German economy. Many of them worked at our base facilities. Two of the officers in our unit had been at Dachau shortly after it was liberated. They told gruesome stories of the piles of bodies that were there and had several photos of those. I never heard whether the gas chamber had been used or not, but we assumed that it had been. Why else would it be there? The crematory was used extensively as Dachau's was one of the few of those around. Bodies from nearby concentration/work camps were shipped by rail or truck to Dachau for cremation. That accounted for the stacks of bodies in and around the railroad cars at the time of liberation. As to the above description of the unit of the 42nd Division liberating the camp, there has been a long-standing dispute between the 42nd ("Rainbow") and the 45th ("Thunderbird") Divisions as to who "liberated" the camp. Both were at opposite ends of the camp, but I think that the 2nd Battalion, 354th Regiment of the 45th was the first unit INTO the camp. That is why while a unit of the 42nd was accepting the surrender of the camp by a German officer at the main gate, they heard shots inside the camp. The unit from the 45th was already inside the camp, having entered from the rear, close to where the prisoners were enclosed. That unit had a bried firefight with a few remaining SS guards; got some of them to surrender; then, while they were lined up, a trigger-happy GI, infuriated by the devastation and gruesome sights he had seen, began to machine gun the SS prisoners, before he was stopped by the Infantry commander, Lt. Col. Felix (Larry) Sparks.It was Sparks and his men that greeted the Dachau prisoners and it was Sparks who, acting upon orders from his Regimental Commander, locked off the prison portion of the camp to await medical treatment and proper feeding and care for the starving prisoners. Sparks, whose orders were to not permit access to anyone into the prison camp, denied access to a Lt. General and the young Life reporter he was escorting, Marguerite Higgins (recently honored with a US postage stamp). The General later tried to have Sparks court-martialed for this, but Gen. George Patton threw out the charges. The 45th part in the liberation of Dachau is told very well at that Division"s excellent museum in Oklahoma City. A special room is set aside and a very well done video is narrated by Sparks, who after the war, commanded the Colorado National Guard and reached the rank of Brigadier General. Sorry to digress but thought that should be set forth here. All above are correct that the local Germans denied any knowledge of what went on at Dachau. Yet I was frequently offered photos of stacks of bodies awaiting cremation and of smiling workers putting bodies into the ovens, none of which I purchased. I was surprised by the mention of "Spanish Army" units liberating Dachau and, as stated above, I doubt it. The Spanish were theoretically neutral during the war although they did furnish units to the Germans. I think there was a "Condor" Division on the Eastern Front. As the 45th Division was originally composed of the National Guards from Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico and Oklahoma, there were a number of Hispanic-Americans in the Division and perhaps that led to the "Spanish" inference. So many of the writers above mention the grim and gray weather at the time of their visits. Certainly we had a lot of those days, but it is a very pleasant part of Bavaria. The town of Dachau is a beautiful Bavarian town, located just 12 miles from Munich. I recommend a tour of the town and a visit to the Schloss at the top of the hill. Our BOQ was in a small Tyrolean style building that formerly held the German nurses at the camp, located in the middle of a 9-hole golf course. As I understood it, it is estimated that about 20,000-30,000 prisoners died or were killed at the Dachau camp. I remember we had small flags of most of the countries represented in those deaths affixed to a wall at the side of the cremation ovens. I remember being surprised to see the US and British flags included. I believe I heard that perhaps 200,000-250,000 bodies were cremated there. Also, in 1957, a former plowing a field a few miles away dug up a mass grave of bodies evidently hastily buried by the SS in the final days of the war. I visited the museum in 1963 when it was first established and was very impressed by how it was presented. In 1992, I also encountered the unfortunate Monday closing (on a very grim and gray day), so I didn't get to revisit. Like so many others, my impression is that the photos above are too sterile and antiseptic to convey the true horror of the real conditions of the Dachau camp, as well as the other camps that were even more gruesome. Larry Reno

Jim Sains , August 01, 2007; 12:06 P.M.

May I add a bit more information on this camp. I was a visitor there in 1950 as a young man. The main camp was still populated in smaller numbers with prisoners who had yet to find places or families to send them to. So, the focus on the visit was the area outside the main camp section where the gas chambers/shower, crematorium, blood ditch and lab were. If anyone says the showers weren't used, it is either a cover up or a lie. In addition a room at the other end of the building past where the ovens were, was still marked with blood writings on the walls from those who were still alive but probably taking their last breaths. For a small boy, these scenes were impacting, however too young to know the full scope of the tragedy. We were also shown the remainder of the gallows and the "shooting range". The book we bought which was in 3 languages was titled, "Nie Wieder"...(Never again). I revisited the camp in 1990 and it is indeed quite a memorial. My first impression was that it was too sterile to be able to show the real story. I know the barracks were too far gone to survive, but to eliminate some of the settings and clean them up seemed like the wrong thing to do. The memorials were very fitting, but had the new generations had the chance to see what the camp liberators saw (or nearly saw) the message would have an even more impact. Nonetheless, upon my last visit, it still affected me and my wife. It will forever.

Rebecca R , August 06, 2007; 10:47 A.M.

I visited Dachau with my three friends during our travels on a semester overseas. We knew we couldn't leave the vicinity of Munchen without going to the concentration camp. We wanted to go but we didn't want to end our beautiful trip to Germany on such a low note. I brought my camera, ready to snap away at the gates, the gas chambers, and the like- but when I stepped in through the gates on that freezing day in October, I could not make myself take any pictures. I won't need any pictures to remember what I felt or saw that day. I only know that it was dark, cloudy and miserably cold. I was wearing two layers of socks and several layers of clothing and I just could not stay warm. Stamping my feet outside in the large open space that was where hundreds of prisoners would stand naked for hours for roll call humbled me beyond expression. I could not imagine the cold and humiliation, standing naked in such a hopeless place. I did not feel warmer after thinking about this, but I did feel ashamed and ungrateful. I think every 21 year old should have such an experience. It changed everything. When I came back to the U.S. a couple of months later, I could never see anything the same way again...and I hope that I never lose that sense of awareness.

Emily Davidson , November 19, 2007; 06:01 P.M.

My tour group and I, as part of the Florida Ambassadors of Music, went to visit the Dachau concentration camp on our way to Rotenburg Germany. Many of the people that came with us didn't care, they were in no way directly affected by what happened while I and my friends, despite also not having been directly affected still got the effect of the camp. I was actually rather glad when I started looking through the rooms and found that were was every group of people imprisoned in the camp accounted for, not just the Jews and the Gypsies but also the invalids, the Catholics and the soldiers from France and Italy and so many other countries. I wanted so badly to say that these people should be appreciated for their sacrifice too, athough they were the ones rarely spoken about and as my final paper for that year in my English class, I wrote about just that. However there was another thing I noticed as well. While I was there a German version of the American JROTC program was also visiting the camp and although my German is admittedly rusty, I could vaguely make out that the teacher who had brought them there was showing them what happened when one blindly follows orders. "If the soldiers had had the guts to speak up against these orders they were given," he was basically saying, keep in mind I am paraphrasing, "then these horrific acts would probably not have happened." I was also told by a friend of mine who lives in Austria that Germany especially spends their whole high school career learning about what went wrong during that time to ensure that the German people never fall into the same trap again. The crimes committed in these camps were beyond human judgement and the court systems, I find, failed to punish those guilty of the very concept of these camps, let alone what should be done in them, properly. There is no punishment we humans could inflict on them appropriate for the Hell on Earth they created for so many people. The only thing we could do now is watch carefully to make sure this never happens anywhere else in the world ever again.

Carlos W. Wagner , January 11, 2008; 04:06 P.M.

In early August of 1967 my college roommate and me visited Dachau. It made a lasting imprint on each of us. His grandfather had represented Germany in the 1916 Olympics and my grandfather had been an alternate to the US rifle team in those olympics. Man's inhumanity to man should never supprise me, but it always does. And I guess I look for man's humanity to man even harder and in more places. CWW

robert thompson , July 09, 2008; 08:16 A.M.

My trip was almost twenty years ago but still is very much alive in my memory to this day. I was only 28 when I went to Europe with my friends to have a good time. The one place I had to visit in my three week journey was Dachau. The train ride from Munich was routine until we got off at Dachau. The 15 minute walk was done in silence as was much of our time on the grounds. My strong memory was one of extreme sadness, walking throughout the entire complex with very little talking as you looked at places where people were routinely disgraced and/or killed. It is hard to imagine what went on at Dachau and the other camps in Europe but for me the time there was important (and I am not even sure why it was absolutely necessary for me to go there but I did). God Bless all those souls who walked through those gates and what happened to them there.


Add a comment